Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Thursday, April 25, 2024 78° Today's Paper


Modern nations must value first peoples above earnings

When Hokule‘a first sailed to Tahiti in 1976 using only noninstrument navigation, it became a major catalyst not only for the Hawaiian cultural renaissance, but also for a broader awakening among indigenous peoples throughout Polynesia. Hokule‘a continues this legacy, touching many during its around-the-world voyage.

Hokule‘a is now approaching Brazil after sailing across the Atlantic from South Africa on the longest leg of its 41-year history. We are aware that our destination is home to as many as 40 tribal cultures with whom no contact has ever been made. Brazil is also home to many more native peoples who have become extinct, endangered or displaced as the result of mining and large-scale commercial farming. There remains much to be done to protect and perpetuate these first peoples. Doing so is not only the right thing, it will also help Brazilian society become healthier and more cohesive.

During the around-the-world voyage, we first visited countless friends in the South Pacific who maintain their own vital, traditional Polynesian voyaging communities. Since leaving New Zealand, we have met Aboriginal tribes in Australia, the Melanesians of Thursday Island and Bushmen of the Kalahari. I also had an opportunity to meet with Zulu and Xhosa tribespeople while in South Africa. Each offers ancient wisdom and unique insights for modern challenges.

An estimated 2.5 million indigenous Amerindians were living in what is today Brazil when the Portuguese arrived there in the 16th century. However, now roughly half of the population of 206 million is of mixed ethnicity, including many of whom have ancestors who were among the 4 million people torn from their cultural fabric in Africa and taken to Brazil as slaves. The scars of displacement and slavery are not easily healed and, generations later, have a way of making their imprint on modern society.

Like South Africa, Brazil is among the BRICS countries (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) that, before the Great Recession, were a model for rapid economic development. Both countries promised their people that the economic bounty would be used for reconciliation and resolution of wealth disparities. Unfortunately, now the economies of both South Africa and Brazil are suffering because of a drop in demand from China for their natural resources. The currencies of both countries face devaluation, and both countries are battling high inflation and discontent among their electorates.

Brazil, in particular, had anticipated that by now the vast pre-SALT (Strategic Arms Limitation Talks) oil and gas fields beneath the ocean off the coast of Rio de Janeiro would have been tapped and that oil prices would be twice what they are today. Additionally, Brazilian politicians are accused of taking large bribes from builders in exchange for contracts to develop these oil fields. Unfortunately, while it is always a challenge to protect the rights of indigenous and disaffected peoples in times of plenty, wealth disparities tend to worsen when the going gets rough.

Its government knows that all eyes will be on Brazil this summer when it hosts the Olympics. Eduardo Paes, mayor of Rio de Janeiro, intends for the games to serve the city and its people and has developed a strategy that will benefit the underserved once the games are over. His intention is that for every dollar spent on the games, $5 will go toward improving the quality of life for Rio’s urban population, including an expansion of public transportation, environmental controls, utilities and waste management, and the creation of a new control center for emergencies. While private money will go directly toward the games, public money will be invested in education and health initiatives such as repairing dilapidated working-class neighborhoods. In fact, a temporary handball stadium built for the games will be converted into four public schools after the Olympics.

The caring spirit behind the plan to ensure that inhabitants of Rio’s urban metropolis enjoy a long-term benefit from the Olympic Games must extend to the rest of the country, including Brazil’s indigenous people and its environment. Indigenous peoples have a great deal of wisdom to offer Brazilian society, including the ability to model a respectful and sustainable relationship to the land and a cohesive cultural fabric, which is sorely needed. To care for the environment, its people and the indigenous culture is the essence of “Malama Honua,” the mission for Hokule‘a’s around-the-world voyage.


Ira Zunin, M.D., M.P.H., M.B.A., is medical director of Manakai o Malama Integrated Healthcare Group and Rehabilitation Center and CEO of Global Advisory Services Inc. Submit your questions to info@manakaiomalama.com.


12 responses to “Modern nations must value first peoples above earnings”

  1. mikethenovice says:

    Democrats want to close the pay inequality gap between Wall Street and Main Street. Republicans want to increase it.

  2. mikethenovice says:

    I’m alright with Wall Street getting their huge pay package as long as it is not at the expense of Main Street.

  3. Mythman says:

    Besides me is anyone else having a hard time figuring out what Ira is preaching in rants like this one?

    • serious says:

      Myth, it’s not just you. When you tell a story it’s the beginning, the middle and the end—Ira seems to have tossed them into a hat and grabbed whatever came first

    • oxtail01 says:

      Not hard to figure at all. The writer is in dream world, filled with kumbaya, let’s dance around the campfire sentimentality. The carp about Brazil is so nauseatingly ignorant and bad, just as the headline of the article. People who write articles like this are, in essence, very narrow minded people who thinks that just sounding good will make things right. The problem is that they NEVER offer any concrete, actionable ideas. PUKE TIME!

  4. justmyview371 says:

    The concept of first peoples is the embodiment of discrimination and inequality. “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”

  5. Bothrops says:

    More to the point BOTH Brazil and South Africa have become amazing corrupt governments and this is threatening their entire economies.

    Also, “ndigenous peoples have a great deal of wisdom to offer Brazilian society, including the ability to model a respectful and sustainable relationship to the land ” Everyone says this but where is the evidence for the wisdom or the ability? Brazil has gone according to the author, from 2.5 Native Americans when the Portugese arrived to 206 million today. What may have been sustainable once is very different when you have 100 times more people..

Leave a Reply