Monday, November 30, 2015         


 Print   Email   Comment | View 0 Comments   Most Popular   Save   Post   Retweet

Familiar turf for lawyer of Tucson shooting rampage suspect

By Joseph Goldstein and Marc Lacey

New York Times


TUCSON, Ariz. » Judy Clarke, the public defender for the man charged in the Tucson shooting rampage, Jared L. Loughner, has made motions on his behalf and entered a plea for him of not guilty. But one of her most essential acts of lawyering came when she patted Loughner on the back in court last month, leaned in close and whispered in his ear.

For the small cadre of lawyers specializing in federal death penalty cases, getting the defendant to trust them, or just to grudgingly accept them, can be half the battle. That is especially true when mental illness is a factor, as it may be in the case of Loughner, a troubled young man accused of opening fire on a crowd on Jan. 8 in an attempt to kill Rep. Gabrielle Giffords.

In her unassuming, almost motherly way, Clarke excels at getting close to people implicated in awful crimes. In jailhouse meetings that can stretch most of the day, she listens intently and grows to know her outcast clients in a way few ever have in their troubled lives, colleagues say.

Still, Clarke, who has made a name for herself representing notorious murderers and terrorists, sometimes falls short. One client threatened to kill her during his trial. More than one has tried to dump her midway through.

How Loughner and Clark get along, or fail to, will set the course for how the criminal case unfolds. One of Clarke's biggest challenges may be persuading Loughner to allow her to raise questions about his mental health; that issue led to conflict between Clarke and some of her previous clients, like the Unabomber, Theodore J. Kaczynski, and the al-Qaida operative Zacarias Moussaoui.

"It could go many different ways," said Michael First, a psychiatrist who has worked on a case with Clarke. "He could be totally acknowledging he's mentally ill, or he could be the Kaczynski and Moussaoui type and be absolutely adamant there is nothing wrong with him."

Kaczynski severed ties with Clarke and the rest of his legal team when they pushed the idea of presenting his mental illness to the jury as a reason to spare his life. Once a mathematician, he was proud of his mind and found his lawyers' suggestion offensive.

And Moussaoui, who faced the death penalty on charges that he helped plan the Sept. 11 attacks, opposed the efforts of his legal team, which Clarke was assisting, to portray him as mentally ill. First recalled spending hours outside Moussaoui's cell, being rebuffed in his efforts to coax him into a conversation.

Next to nothing is known of what Loughner and Clarke have spoken about in the month since he was arrested. But it is unlikely, former colleagues of Clarke say, that she and her two co-counsels, Mark Fleming and Reuben C. Cahn, are very far along in planning his defense. It is possible, lawyers say, that they have not even broached the extent of Loughner's mental illness or the shooting that left six dead and 13 wounded, among them Giffords, who is recovering in a rehabilitation center in Houston.

Clarke, rather than focusing on her clients' innocence, spends much of her defense work trying to persuade jurors to spare her clients' lives. She does this by presenting what lawyers call a "mitigating social history" — a narrative of abuse, violence or mental illness that the defendant may have suffered. She sends investigators to find grade-school teachers, former girlfriends, classmates, anyone who can provide insight into what made her client go awry.

Clarke rarely gives interviews to the news media, but she did explain her philosophy last year in a law school publication at Washington and Lee University in Virginia. "None of us, including those accused of crime, wants to be defined by the worst moment or worst day of our lives," she said.

In representing Susan Smith, a South Carolina mother who killed her two boys, Clarke focused the jury's attention on the facts that Smith's father had committed suicide and that her stepfather had sexually abused her.

"She was able to change her from Susan the monster to Susan the victim," said Tommy Pope, a South Carolina legislator who prosecuted the case against Smith. A jury spared her life.

In her court arguments, Clarke can be quite vehement, lawyers who have seen her at work say. Clarke once told The Los Angeles Times: "I like the antagonism. I like the adversarial nature of the business. I love all of that."

But her demeanor changes to that of a social worker when meeting with her clients one on one.

"Even people who are quite mentally ill can identify someone who is real and who wants to protect them," said David Bruck, a lawyer at Washington and Lee University's School of Law who has worked with Clarke. "She's a great listener, and she's focused on the client. She tries to understand the client. The client becomes her world."


Familiar turf for lawyer of Tucson shooting rampage suspect

Giffords moved to nearby rehab hospital in Houston

Tucson shootings reawaken pain from Virginia Tech

Survivors of rampage in Tucson struggle with 'What if?'

Husband broke down after incorrect Giffords report

Martin Luther King III: Arizona shootings underscore father's message

Hundreds come out for Arizona girl's funeral

Some question pep rally atmosphere at Obama speech

Major milestone: Wounded Giffords moves arms, legs

Documents detail Arizona suspect's college outbursts

Officials: Frenetic morning for rampage suspect

Shooting suspect fell through mental health cracks

Obama tells polarized nation: 'We can be better'

Church agrees to not protest Arizona funerals

Emotional House pays tribute to Arizona victims

Palin: Journalists incite hatred after shooting

Hundreds attend Mass to remember victims

Lawmakers planning to carry weapons

Legislators approve ban on protests near funerals

Alleged shooter's written notes point to plans

Rapid progress by Giffords prompts optimistic prognosis

Tucson suspect's troubles did not keep him from gun

Lawmakers vote to ban picketing at Tucson funerals

Top lawyer to represent accused Arizona gunman

Parents of Arizona shooting suspect apologize; investigators reveal new details

A tragedy in Tucson, and more arguing on talk TV

Defense attorney a death penalty trial ace

Suspect held as U.S. reflects

Arizona suspect could face death in deadly attack

Insanity defense difficult for shooting suspect

Abercrombie orders state flags at half-staff for Arizona shooting victims

Dallas Green thanks baseball family for support

Dad remembers slain aide as friendly, steady, kind

Congresswoman's condition stable; 8 hospitalized

Unclear whether shooter's motivation was political

9-year-old shooting victim was aspiring politician

Thumbnail sketches of victims in Tucson shooting

Congresswoman's intern stanched blood from gunshot

Arizona tragedy gives Congress reason to reflect

Authorities charge man, 22, with assassination try

Investigators examine possible link to anti-government group

Doctors optimistic, but Giffords in for long recovery

Obama calls for moment of silence Monday morning

Shooting suspect's nihilism rose with isolation

Shooting suspect's campus troubles led to suspension, officials say

Dallas Green's grandchild killed in Arizona shooting

'A tragedy for our entire country'

Stunned isle leaders have hope for recovery

Giffords: A Democrat who wins in conservative district

Tucson rampage casts light on toxic political tone

Arizona Rep. Giffords shot, 6 killed in rampage

Arizona's chief fed judge among shooting victims

Giffords among lawmakers getting threats last year

Isles' U.S. House members, governor, have kind words for Giffords

McCain: Shooting a 'terrible, terrible' tragedy

 Print   Email   Comment | View 0 Comments   Most Popular   Save   Post   Retweet

You must be subscribed to participate in discussions

Latest News/Updates