Monday, July 28, 2014         

 Print   Email   Comment | View 13 Comments   Most Popular   Save   Post   Retweet

Man sent back to prison for 90 years after court error

By Sadie Gurman

Associated Press

LAST UPDATED: 11:50 p.m. HST, May 08, 2014

AURORA, Colo. » Rene Lima-Marin's wife told her two young sons their father had to go to work the night in January when a team of police officers led her husband away in handcuffs.

It had been nearly six years since he left prison, and his family believed he had paid his debt to society.

But Lima-Marin should have stayed behind bars for the rest of his life. A court clerk's error led to his release in 2008 — 90 years too soon. Colorado authorities did not discover the mistake until January and immediately sent him back to prison to serve the rest of his 98-year sentence for armed robbery.

Lima-Marin's case comes as other clerical errors have let criminals evade prison time. In Missouri, a judge this week freed a convicted robber who didn't report to prison — despite trying to do so — for 13 years because of a clerical mistake. A Los Angeles murder suspect who was accidentally freed last year due to a clerk's error was captured on Thursday.

And in Colorado, an inmate mistakenly released four years early due to such a mistake killed the state's corrections chief at his front door last year. That prompted Gov. John Hickenlooper to order an audit of thousands of inmates' records to ensure they are serving the correct sentences. Lima-Marin wasn't part of the audit because it focused on other kinds of felonies, corrections department spokeswoman Adrienne Jacobson said.

Lima-Marin and another man were convicted in 2000 after robbing two Aurora video stores when Lima-Marin was 20. In one robbery, they ordered employees into a back room at gunpoint, and a worker was ordered to the floor as they demanded money from a safe.

A judge sentenced Lima-Marin to serve back-to-back sentences on eight convictions, for a total of 98 years. But a court clerk mistakenly wrote in his file that the sentences were to run at the same time. Corrections officials depend on that file to determine how much time an inmate should serve.

Lima-Marin was released on parole in 2008 after serving just eight years.

He set about building his life — while, prosecutors say, being fully aware of the clerical error and never notifying authorities.

Lima-Marin, now 35, started selling coupon books door-to-door, and more recently became skilled at cutting and installing windows. He reconnected with his former girlfriend, Jasmine Lima-Marin, and they married in July in a ceremony that also celebrated his completion of five years of parole. He was active in church and helped coach soccer.

Lima-Marin helped Jasmine raise her 7-year-old son, Justus. Soon, they had another boy, Josiah, who is now 4. Lima-Marin will be in prison for his birthday party.

"That was his life, raising his kids and being a husband," Jasmine said. "He definitely was not the same person that he was when he went in to prison."

Lima-Marin's co-defendant, Michael Clifton, also would have been mistakenly released early, but the error in his file was uncovered after he filed an appeal in his case. Clifton is serving 98 years in prison.

Lima-Marin filed his own appeal in 2000 but, in a rare move, asked that it be dismissed less than a year later. Prosecutors say that showed he was aware of the clerical error before his release and feared any further court action would call attention to it.

Rich Orman, an Arapahoe County senior deputy district attorney, said he was alerted to the error in January by a former prosecutor who handled Lima-Marin's case and was checking on its status. Orman quickly filed a motion to send Lima-Marin back to prison. A judge agreed.

"He should go back because the law requires the sentence he received. This was a number of very serious criminal offenses, and anything less would be inappropriate," Orman said. "He should not be able to escape the minimum sentence due to a clerical error."

Jacobson, with the state corrections department, said it was the court that made the mistake and prison officials would not have known Lima-Marin was released incorrectly.

Colorado State Public Defender Doug Wilson did not return calls seeking comment. In April, a judge declined to release Lima-Marin at his public defender's request, noting that Lima-Marin knew he should have served 98 years but remained silent about the mistake.

The Associated Press reached out to Lima-Marin for comment but he has not responded.

"We don't have secrets. If he knew there was a mistake, he would have told me," Jasmine said. She said her husband did not try to mask his identity.

The prospect of Lima-Marin remaining imprisoned for nine more decades has devastated his family. They argue his clean life after prison shows he has been punished enough. Jasmine said they are considering another appeal and have reached out to the attorney involved in the recent Missouri case.

"He was given an opportunity to live again and it was taken away from him," Jasmine said.

 Print   Email   Comment | View 13 Comments   Most Popular   Save   Post   Retweet

You must be subscribed to participate in discussions
By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. Because only subscribers are allowed to comment, we have your personal information and are able to contact you. If your comments are inappropriate, you may receive a warning, and if you persist with such comments you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, email commentfeedback@staradvertiser.com.
Leave a comment

Please login to leave a comment.
wizard417 wrote:
98 years for armed robbery, people get less than that for murder. he has shown that he has changed and has built a life and has become a productive member of society,why would government want to spend hundreds of thousands of dollar to keep him in prison. because it's the law?
on May 9,2014 | 03:35AM
wiliki wrote:
It looks like he's a person of color. We tend to get harsher sentences because we "deserve" them-- for the evil persons that we are. Colorado is NOT Hawaii.
on May 9,2014 | 10:34AM
Nocturnal wrote:
You get less for that for raping little kids and putting the video of that rape onto the Internet. It's a sickening world we live in where pedophiles get probation and armed robbers get 98 years.
on May 9,2014 | 06:27PM
bpet wrote:
Not too sure about the justice system . . .rape and murder get far less time in jail than two armed robberies?
on May 9,2014 | 04:07AM
OregonRedRaider wrote:
you make a mistake, you do the time, so what about the person that made the clerical mistake?? by the way they are treating this, shouldn't that person be behind bars too? and like the post stated above, rapist and murderers get less time, go figure....
on May 9,2014 | 04:38AM
Slow wrote:
The US leads the entire world in incarceration of it's citizens. Why?
on May 9,2014 | 07:10AM
People have a great lack of respect for property, ethics and moral standards, not to mention respect for people in general.
on May 9,2014 | 10:34AM
Jerry_D wrote:
Let a man out of jail under the pretenses that he's done his time, allow him to turn his life around, then lock him back up in jail for the rest of his life? Sounds like cruel and unusual punishment to me.
on May 9,2014 | 07:42AM
jmarie wrote:
One more cry baby, don;t do the crime if you can't do the time.
on May 9,2014 | 07:52AM
XML808 wrote:
His lack of recidivism and apparent rehabilitation are what incarceration is supposed to achieve, isn't it? So punishing him for a court error is counter productive and a gross injustice.
on May 9,2014 | 07:54AM
DAGR81 wrote:
clerical errors or bribery?
on May 9,2014 | 09:46AM
bluebowl wrote:
Sounds like a good cause for Change.org get enough signatures and petition the governor.
on May 9,2014 | 11:25AM
Olopala wrote:
So much for the idea that prison time can bring about rehabilitation if properly administrated and accepted. It won't even be recognized when it occurs.
on May 9,2014 | 04:19PM
Breaking News