Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Thursday, December 12, 2024 79° Today's Paper


Top News

Michigan lawmakers: As Congress bickers, Flint suffers

ASSOCIATED PRESS

Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder testifies before a House Oversight and Government Reform Committee hearing in Washington, Thursday, March 17.

WASHINGTON >> Two years after problems began with the drinking water in Flint, Michigan, and nearly six months after officials declared a public health emergency, a bipartisan congressional effort to aid the predominantly African-American city is idling in the Senate — stalled by the objections of a single senator from Utah.

Rep. Dan Kildee, a Michigan Democrat who represents Flint, says his hometown is struggling while Congress bickers.

“This is not an abstraction. This is 100,000 kids and adults all suffering every single day and it’s pretty frustrating,” Kildee said in an interview. “We will not give up, that’s for sure,” he added, vowing that congressional Republicans “are not going to run out the clock on Flint, Michigan.”

In fact, support for Flint is bipartisan. Michigan’s congressional delegation has unanimously pushed for Flint aid, and Republican Gov. Rick Snyder urged Congress to pass the bipartisan Senate bill “immediately” at an otherwise contentious congressional hearing last week.

Michigan Democratic Sens. Debbie Stabenow and Gary Peters reached agreement with key Republicans last month on a $220 million package to fix and replace lead-contaminated pipes in Flint and other cities.

But the bill remains on hold after Republican Sen. Mike Lee of Utah objected in late February. Lee said Michigan has a budget surplus and does not need federal money to fix the problem.

Stabenow’s frustration has been evident. In an impassioned speech on the Senate floor, she said that as a mother and grandmother, she “can’t imagine the fear and horror” Flint families feel as they are forced — month after month — to use bottled water to drink and bathe.

Like other Americans, Flint residents “assumed that when you get up in the morning and turn on the faucet, when you take a shower or you feed your children, clean water is going to come out of the pipes,” Stabenow said in a March 17 speech. “We all assume that. That is pretty much a basic human right.”

But not in Flint, where the water is tainted with lead.

Flint’s drinking water became tainted when the city switched from the Detroit water system and began drawing from the Flint River in April 2014 to save money. The impoverished city was under state control at the time.

Regulators failed to ensure the water was treated properly and lead from aging pipes leached into the water supply.

Elevated lead levels have been found in at least 325 people, including 221 children. Lead contamination has been linked to learning disabilities and other problems.

Stabenow, in her Senate speech, said she and other lawmakers have been pushing since January to pass a bill to help Flint, “yet the children of Flint are still waiting. The children of Flint need our help. We have a bipartisan bill, and we need a vote.”

Lee said he, too, wants a vote — but only if the bill is paid for in what he considers an honest manner. Not only that, legislation labeled as helping Flint actually allows cities across the country to replace aging infrastructure where lead lurks as potential health hazard, he said.

“What’s really happening here is that Washington politicians are using the crisis in Flint as an excuse to funnel taxpayer money to their own home states, and trying to sneak it through the Senate without proper debate and amendment. I respectfully object,” Lee said in a statement.

The Senate bill would be paid for by redirecting up to $250 million in unspent money from an Energy Department loan program for high-tech cars. Lee, a freshman who was elected with the help of the tea party, does not object to redirecting money to Flint, but he wants to ensure that money committed to Flint does not add to the federal deficit, said spokesman Conn Carroll.

Stabenow and Peters, whose state is the hub of U.S. auto manufacturing, want to protect that Energy Department program, which involves loans issued through the Advanced Technology Vehicles Manufacturing program, a remnant of the 2009 economic stimulus law.

While lawmakers continue to negotiate — and point fingers over who’s to blame for the Flint crisis — Kildee said the time to act is now.

“The people in Flint are American citizens and they are in crisis,” he said. “When there is a disaster and Americans face a crisis, we all pitch in, and the people of Flint deserve that.”

6 responses to “Michigan lawmakers: As Congress bickers, Flint suffers”

  1. Ronin006 says:

    Flint’s drinking water became tainted when the city switched from the Detroit water system and began drawing from the Flint River in April 2014 to save money. It seems to me the problem would be solved if Flint switch back to the Detroit water system.

    • klastri says:

      It seems to you? Then you haven’t read anything about what happened to those pipes when they were exposed to Flint River water. Can’t you just spend five minutes doing research on anything before commenting? Maybe try that just once?

      • Ronin006 says:

        Klastri, The Omnipotent, the know-it-all, why do you think you are so much smarter than others who comment about stories in the SA? FYI, the pipes through which Flint’s water has flowed since the 1960s contain lead, but it was not a problem because the water Flint purchased from the Detroit was treated with orthophosphate, a chemical used in water systems throughout the country to coat pipes as water flows through them, thus preventing lead from leaching into water supplies. In 2014, in an attempt to save money, Flint switched to using water from the Flint River. The river water contains high levels of chlorine, which is highly corrosive to iron and lead. Moreover, the water was not treated with orthophosphate to prevent lead from leaching. That is what caused Flint’s problem. The application of a little logic would suggest that if Flint switches back to Detroit’s water system, the pipes would get recoated with orthophosphate to prevent leaching, thus eliminated the need to spend millions of dollars digging up and replacing thousands of miles of water pipes which could take many years to complete. Even dummies should know that.

      • lee1957 says:

        Ditto. Switching back won’t solve the problem.

Leave a Reply