Obama’s persuasive power put to test as Clinton seeks turnout
WASHINGTON » Hillary Clinton is counting on Barack Obama to win her the White House, as the one Democrat who can draw reluctant young voters, African Americans and Hispanics to the polls.
But history shows that when his name isn’t on the ballot, Obama doesn’t always deliver.
Obama hit the campaign trail for seven Democratic gubernatorial candidates in 2014; five of them lost. And turnout in five neighborhoods where he appeared that year was lower than in the 2010 midterm election.
In Maryland, one of the most heavily Democratic states in the nation, more than 8,000 people stood in line for hours before packing a high school gym in 2014 to hear Obama stump for Anthony Brown, then the state’s lieutenant governor, who was running for governor.
“You’ve got to vote,” Obama told the cheering crowd in Prince George’s County, where he had won 90 percent of the vote two years earlier. “No excuses.”
Two weeks later on Election Day, the crowd had vanished. The same high school was a polling place, but turnout dipped 2.7 percentage points from four years earlier, to 30 percent. It was half what it was when Obama himself was first elected in 2008. Brown lost to Larry Hogan, who became only the second Republican governor in the state in nearly 50 years.
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with top news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It's FREE!
“The notion is that Obama is the best surrogate to speak to his strongest supporters to turn out in the support of others,” Lara Brown, interim director at George Washington University’s Graduate School of Political Management, said in an interview. “But part of his coalition are voters who are not necessarily reliable voters, so I think it is a higher bar for him to try to turn out his voters.”
Obama is more popular today than in 2014, with an approval rating that’s hovered near or above 50 percent this year. And he’s more invested in the 2016 election, which he considers a referendum on his presidency. He plans to spend one to two days a week campaigning for Clinton until Election Day, the White House has said.
Part of Obama’s mission is to increase enthusiasm among “African Americans, young people, and people of all ages who need an extra boost to remember what is at stake,” said White House spokeswoman Jennifer Friedman.
Part of Obama’s challenge is that while much of his base turned out for him, personally, the voters have no particular attachment to politics. First-time voters “caught up in the zeitgeist of electing and re-electing the first African-American president” are less likely to cast ballots in 2016 than habitual voters, said Andra Gillespie, who teaches political science at Emory University in Atlanta and has studied Obama’s effect on turnout. An Obama rally isn’t enough to get them to the polls for Clinton, she said.
“Rallies are great but rallies don’t vote,” Gillespie said. “What is important for campaigns to do is work on their ground game.”
As Obama’s approval ratings dipped to all-time lows in the fall of 2014, many Democratic candidates in competitive races kept the president at arm’s length, especially after he announced that his policies “were on the ballot” that November. Republicans hammered Democrats with television ads highlighting that remark.
The candidates that did invite Obama onto the campaign trail deployed the president specifically to boost turnout among the Democratic base. In each of his seven campaign appearances, Obama visited heavily Democratic communities where he had won at least 85 percent of the vote in 2012 — including wards in Milwaukee and Chicago that went 99 percent for the president.
Obama traveled to college campuses and held rallies in predominantly black neighborhoods in Chicago, Philadelphia, Detroit and Bridgeport, Connecticut, to gin up enthusiasm among the young people and minorities that had voted for him in droves. His 2014 campaign sprint offers some insight into how the Clinton team plans to utilize him over the next three weeks as it battles voter apathy.
After campaigning for Brown in Maryland in October 2014, Obama flew to his home town, where some 6,000 people awaited his arrival at Chicago State University. At the mostly black school, Obama urged voters to get their politically inactive relatives to the polls for then-Gov. Pat Quinn, who was running for re-election.
“You’ve got to find cousin Pookie,” he said. “He’s sitting on the couch right now watching football; hasn’t voted in the last five elections. You’ve got to grab him and tell him to go vote.”
Pookie stayed on the couch. Turnout in Chicago’s 9th Ward, where the university is located, fell slightly from 2010, and the city saw an overall 7 percent decline in voting. Quinn lost to venture capitalist Bruce Rauner, who became the first Republican governor of Illinois since 2003.
In Philadelphia’s Ward 47, where Obama led a November rally for gubernatorial contender Tom Wolf, voter turnout fell to 24 percent, with fewer than half the people who backed Obama in 2012 casting ballots. Wolf still managed to defeat incumbent Republican Tom Corbett, whose approval ratings at the time were among the nation’s lowest.
To be sure, Obama faced historic odds as he tried to motivate voters during a midterm election in which the majority of Americans stayed home. Nationwide, turnout fell to a 72-year low, as only 36 percent of eligible voters cast ballots.
As is typical during recent midterm elections, Republicans were more likely to vote than Democrats. Even in Portland, Maine, which saw an increase in turnout after Obama’s 2014 visit, the Democratic candidate for governor lost amid a Republican wave. Republicans also picked up the governorship in heavily Democratic Massachusetts, where Obama held no campaign events.
The political dynamic has turned sharply in Clinton’s favor over the past two weeks, though, after she bested Republican Donald Trump in their first debate and a 2005 video emerged of Trump boasting about groping women. After he said, in his second debate with Clinton, that he never committed the acts described in the video, at least five women came forward with accusations that he had groped or otherwise assaulted them.
Trump has denied the allegations. With his campaign in turmoil, he’s resorting to a turnout strategy of his own: an attempt to suppress enthusiasm and votes for Clinton by focusing on her husband Bill Clinton’s infidelities, in the hope that young, socially liberal voters unfamiliar with the former president’s sex scandals will become disillusioned.
Obama could be particularly effective at persuading black voters to cast ballots for Clinton, said Alexsis Rodgers, political director for the Virginia Young Democrats. In 2012, blacks voted at a higher rate than whites for the first time, according to Census figures.
Some young people and black voters are “a little apathetic” about this election, Rodgers said, but could be motivated by a personal appeal from Obama. Other Clinton surrogates including first lady Michelle Obama and Sen. Bernie Sanders are also trying explicitly to reach disaffected voters.
It’s especially difficult to project turnout this year, said Geoffrey Skelley, associate editor of Sabato’s Crystal Ball, the University of Virginia Center for Politics newsletter on campaigns. Polls show Americans are watching the race more closely than previous ones, but are also more turned off by what they see, he said.
When Obama was on the ballot, Obama-driven turnout was crucial, helping decide close elections in 2008 and 2012 in competitive states like North Carolina, Ohio and Pennsylvania, said William Frey, a demographer with the Brookings Institution in Washington.
Frey ran a model of the 2012 election, adjusting the turnout to 2004 levels, that determined former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney may have won if the Obama coalition stayed home.
“It was pretty close,” he said in a telephone interview. “Turnout made a difference.”
——
(With assistance from Joshua Green)
——
©2016 Bloomberg News
20 responses to “Obama’s persuasive power put to test as Clinton seeks turnout”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
President Obama is correctly helping to elect Mrs. Clinton and at the same time, help to defeat Mr Trump – a pathetic serial felon and psychotic.
Thanks, Mr. President!
Shame on you Zealot Klastri, claiming to be an attorney, you should no better than to call Trump a felon, I do not remember Trump being convicted of anything. Stop embarrassing yourself. Then again having a hero like Hilliar I can understand why. Thanks Mr. President for helping Trump “pookie” is staying home again.
Are you angry because you can’t form coherent sentences, and can’t spell?
No not angry at all. I just enjoy your ignorance although it would not be as enjoyable if you would not have claimed to be someone your not. We all see through your lies just like we see through Hilliar.
Davcon, Klastri knows more than you will ever begin to imagine, that said, thats not a very high bar–think of a thirteen year old beagle.
Which then begs the question: what’s your education level, where did you go to school, what did you do in your career, if any??
Crickets, chip chirp….awkward silence.
davcon – It’s “someone you’re not. Not “someone your (SIC) not.”
And you think I’m the ignorant one? Understood!
“Persuasive”? Yea in persuading goofballs and the clueless like you. This clowns term cannot end too soon.
Whoa’ control yourself. I’m beginning to worry about you and Ike. Are the two of you competing for Shameless Hero Worshipper of the year? Or is it just my imagination? Little Barry Hussein and the pant-suited one are just like the rest of us, they put their pants on one leg at a time. Except once they have their pants on they make incompetent boobs look competent by comparison. Obamacare is an unmitigated disaster as us uneducated proletarians knew it would be. He and the classified material handling challenged real estate lady have screwed up things in the middle east so badly the not even John Kerry can fix it. But adult men can use the girls rest room as they please so I guess that’s cool.
Sir, it’s a paragraph not a double decker bus for poorly formed sentences and bastard thoughts.
Maobama trying to help Hillary, a felon who hates women, and women get fooled by her, in the 1990’s when she was first lady no men or women could look at her and could never even say morning to her, they had to keep there head down when she walked by. she decorated the white house Christmas tree with sex toys and condoms, she is a sick woman and that’s what you want as president, god help us.
barry opala does not know his okole from one puka in the sand
tripled our national debt more that all the presidents combined before him
lied about his healthcare plan “if you like you doctor, you can keep your doctor”
enrolled as a foreign student at occidental as an indonesian under barry soetero, and sealed the records
hiliary clinton used insecure servers to send/receive classified material (wikileaks) hacked it and got it all
“20 times” used the “do not recall” answer about destroyed emails
well she is either hiding something or has early signs of dementia. disqualifying her from being president
her open borders ideology will turn america into amerexico
kisds our country goodbye!
You do realize, that most immigrants are not from Mexico???
The U.S. Census Bureau figures show 428,000 new immigrants came from India and China in 2014, more than double the 2005 number. Meanwhile, the number of new immigrants from Mexico dropped by two-thirds, to 240,000. Their number had peaked in 2000, at about 875,000.
Where are you from? Which planet?
President Obama is fighting for his legacy. No matter what he does, no matter what crooked Hillary does, he’ll go down in shame and flames. He’s just plain horrible. It’s so bad you can’t cover up the corruption. He has made America the laughingstock of the World. I’m kind of hoping Trump loses so Crooked Hilliary can deal with the mess she’s created. Allah have mercy on the infidels.
Is that why he has been voted serval years in a row the most respected and popular leader in the world?
http://time.com/4162124/gallup-most-admired-poll/
http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/jul/28/barack-obama/mostly-true-obama-says-world-opinion-us-better-now/
http://www.ndtv.com/india-news/barack-obama-most-popular-leader-in-world-pm-modi-7th-survey-1258432
Wassup SA?
You’re joking again. A failure in all aspects. His legacy will be never again.
Go ahead no preach son–
“If the Republican Party does not evolve, the Republican Party is going to die,” Kasich said in an interview with Business Insider published Saturday.
“The Republican Party cannot be anti-trade, anti-immigrant, not out there practicing the politics of people, you know, the issues surrounding drug addiction and mental illness and the cost of prescription drugs and healthcare and student debt and all of these things are very personal to people now.”
“So I do believe that the party needs to evolve, or I won’t be a part of it,” he said.
Who’s Kasich? Another loser soundly beaten by Mr Trump.
Trump totally closes shop in VA, everything. The end is near, if not already here.
Buahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah.