Police panel: Espero tried to sway key vote
Top News

Police panel: Espero tried to sway key vote

  • BRUCE ASATO / 2015

    Senator Will Espero is being accused of trying to influence a Honolulu Police Commission member to vote against giving a pricey severance to a retiring chief under federal investigation.


    Honolulu Police Commission member Luella Costales, left, listens to testimony during a commission meeting today. The commission is complaining about an email state Sen. Will Espero sent Costales the night before a key vote on whether to give a police chief a severance payment for agreeing to retire amid a federal investigation.

A Hawaii state senator tried to influence a Honolulu Police Commission member to vote against a pricey severance package for a retiring chief under federal investigation, according to a letter from the commission chairman.

State Sen. Will Espero sent an email the night before the vote to Commissioner Luella Costales that said, “If you are thinking of running for office again, your vote tomorrow will be significant.”

Commission Chairman Max Sword complained about Espero’s email in a letter to Senate President Ronald Kouchi.

The tone of the message was “at worst threatening, at best disrespectful and discourteous,” Sword wrote. Kouchi couldn’t immediately be reached for comment today.

Espero has been a critic of the commission and opposed paying former Chief Louis Kealoha $250,000 for agreeing to retire amid the probe into corruption allegations.

Espero said the commission overreacted and he wasn’t trying to influence Costales.

“I was sharing my thoughts on the matter,” he said. “Ultimately it was up to her.”

Espero said Costales has been his friend for more than 15 years and he was simply reminding her that voters would remember where she stood on the severance issue.

Costales said the email didn’t affect her decision to approve the retirement package. She declined further comment.

In the email exchange with Espero, she took offense at the idea that she could be motivated by political ambitions.

“For the record, I have no intention of seeking office again,” she wrote. Espero replied with an apology.

Costales’ term on the commission ended in December, but she remains on the panel until the mayor appoints a replacement. She ran unsuccessfully in 2012 for a state House of Representatives seat in the Honolulu suburb of Mililani.

Randall Roth, who teaches a course in legal ethics at the University of Hawaii law school, said Espero’s email could be interpreted in different ways.

“There are too many additional factors that could help explain what he intended to convey,” Roth said.

Kealoha’s lawyers have denied any wrongdoing related to the federal investigation.

Comments (0)

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Terms of Service. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. Report comments if you believe they do not follow our guidelines.

Having trouble with comments? Learn more here.

Scroll Up