comscore Snowden talks sci-fi, reality in New York via live stream | Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Snowden talks sci-fi, reality in New York via live stream


    Edward Snowden, a former CIA worker before turning whistleblower, speaks via satellite at the IT fair CeBIT in Hanover, Germany, on March 21.

About half an hour into Cory Doctorow’s discussion of his new science-fiction novel, “Walkaway,” at the New York Public Library on May 3, the man interviewing him suddenly froze in midsentence.

The crowd murmured uncomfortably as technicians rushed to the stage to fix the video feed, which beamed a frozen image of Edward J. Snowden, who was some 4,660 miles away in Moscow, onto two large screens.

“Oh, there’s the NSA,” Doctorow joked when the video stalled. “Ed warned us this might happen and said we should just make a joke about the NSA and wait for him to come back.”

Snowden, a former contractor for the National Security Agency who leaked a trove of classified documents that revealed the agency’s vast surveillance operation against hundreds of millions of U.S. citizens and others, has become something of a fugitive hero and pop culture icon. He’s been featured in video games and a graphic novel and is the subject of an Academy Award-winning documentary, “Citizenfour,” as well as a 2016 feature film directed by Oliver Stone. He appeared, via video, in a play with Daniel Radcliffe at the Public Theater. There’s an Edward Snowden action figure.

But it was unusual for Snowden to make an appearance at a New York literary event, where he acted as the interlocutor. “Normally, I don’t ask the questions,” he said at the beginning of the discussion.

He proceeded to ask a lot of them, pressing Doctorow about copyright law, scarcity and abundance, and other economic and political themes in the novel, and whether he intended his book to be an optimistic or pessimistic vision of the future.

“As a science-fiction writer, I’m keenly aware we have no claim to predicting the future,” Doctorow said. “If the future were predictable, I don’t know why I’d bother getting out of bed.”

The event, cheerfully titled “Dystopia, Apocalypse, and Other Sunny Futures,” went remarkably smoothly, considering that Snowden was several time zones away — until it didn’t. The discussion ranged from Ayn Rand to the predictions of economist John Maynard Keynes to the minimalist philosophy of the Japanese tidying guru Marie Kondo.

All of these disparate subjects, somehow, seemed relevant to Doctorow’s novel. “Walkaway” takes place in a futuristic Canada after the collapse of modern society, when wealth gets concentrated in the hands of the ultrarich and the less fortunate scrape by in desolate cities that have been gutted by industrial flight. But the setting is not as bleak as it first seems. Communities of unemployed drifters spring up. In a world with 3-D printers, abundant sources of food and mobile fabricators, the people can make anything they need.

Having Snowden act as the interviewer was a brilliant marketing tactic — the packed auditorium erupted into cheers when his face first appeared on the screens flanking the stage — but it also made philosophical sense. Some of Doctorow’s earlier novels feature rebellious hacker heroes who take on shadowy corporations and tyrannical government agencies and fight the erosion of civil liberties. And Doctorow knew that Snowden was a fan of his work from watching the documentary “Citizenfour” (in one scene, Snowden stands in his hotel room next to a table that holds a copy of Doctorow’s novel “Homeland,” which features a hacktivist protagonist who is deciding whether to leak incriminating government documents). So when his new novel was coming out, he tweeted Snowden and asked if he would consider blurbing it. Snowden enthusiastically agreed.

Just before his video feed faltered, Snowden was speaking passionately about freedom and American values. “This is a country that, many people forget, is born from an act of treason,” he said. “We were all rebels willing to risk the rope in order to create something that was less ordered and more free.” Moments later, as he was talking about how the government’s surveillance of its citizens’ electronic communications violates the Constitution, he was cut off. Doctorow improvised for a bit, and Paul Holdengraber, the director of the library’s “Live” programs, jumped in to ask questions.

About 30 minutes later, the video feed was restored, and Snowden and Doctorow resumed their conversation.

“It is amazing that a technical problem, which never seems to happen, mysteriously pops up when we start talking about the sensitive political things being born from treason,” Snowden said. “And this really brings us to the central point that we get to when it’s past 3 in the morning in Moscow — the things nobody wants you to talk about.”

Comments (0)

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Terms of Service. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. Report comments if you believe they do not follow our guidelines.

Having trouble with comments? Learn more here.

Click here to see our full coverage of the coronavirus outbreak. Submit your coronavirus news tip.

Be the first to know
Get web push notifications from Star-Advertiser when the next breaking story happens — it's FREE! You just need a supported web browser.
Subscribe for this feature

Scroll Up