Mahalo for supporting Honolulu Star-Advertiser. Enjoy this free story!
Environmental and industry advocates have been battling for years over whether the state should end the commercial collection of aquarium fish from Hawaii reefs. The fight led to a court decision that banned the use of fine-mesh nets — the main tool of fish collectors — until an environmental review is completed.
>> Oct. 24, 2012: Plaintiffs sue state Department of Land and Natural Resources, challenging issuance of 50 aquarium permits. DLNR accused of failing to complete environmental review before approving permits.
>> June 24, 2013: Circuit Court determines issuing of aquarium permits not action subject to review under Hawaii Environmental Policy Act.
>> July 18, 2013: Plaintiffs appeal to intermediate court of appeals.
>> Aug. 31, 2016: ICA upholds ruling, affirming that aquarium permits are not subject to environmental review.
>> May 2, 2017: Senate (25-0), House (36-14) pass Senate Bill 1240, prohibiting issuing of new permits for commercial collection of Hawaii aquarium fish.
>> July 11, 2017: Gov. David Ige vetoes bill, saying science doesn’t support claims made in legislation.
>> Sept. 6, 2017: Hawaii Supreme Court rules commercial aquarium permits subject to Hawaii environmental review law but record not adequate to determine whether recreational permits exempt.
>> Sept. 7, 2017: DLNR stops issuing new commercial permits and renewing existing ones.
>> Oct. 27, 2017: Based on high court decision, Circuit Court Judge Jeffrey Crabtree rules all existing permits issued to commercial collectors illegal until appropriate environmental reviews done.
>> Jan. 5, 2018: DLNR announces no aquatic life may be taken for commercial aquarium purposes off West Hawaii until review completed.
>> April 8, 2018: Pet Industry Joint Advisory Council, representing aquarium trade, submits environmental assessments to DLNR for islands of Hawaii and Oahu, maintaining issuing of commercial permits would not have significant environmental impact.
>> April 12, 2018: Judge Crabtree rules all unexpired recreational permits allowing collection with fine-mesh nets void pending environmental reviews.
>> July 26, 2018: DLNR rejects trade’s environmental assessments, requiring more rigorous environmental impact statements. Council working on one for West Hawaii.
Source: Court documents, state records, Honolulu Star-Advertiser research
79