Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Thursday, December 12, 2024 78° Today's Paper


Hawaii News

Despite the low risk, summer ramps up fear of shark encounters

JAMM AQUINO / 2020 
                                Shark sightings are common in Hawaii, with signs posted to warn beachgoers. This one was put up at Kaimana Beach after several sharks were seen pursuing schooling baitfish about 20 yards from shore.
1/2
Swipe or click to see more

JAMM AQUINO / 2020

Shark sightings are common in Hawaii, with signs posted to warn beachgoers. This one was put up at Kaimana Beach after several sharks were seen pursuing schooling baitfish about 20 yards from shore.

NATIONAL OCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION
                                At top, tiger sharks are fitted with satellite tags near Maui as part of a Pacific Islands Ocean Observing System tracking study.
2/2
Swipe or click to see more

NATIONAL OCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION

At top, tiger sharks are fitted with satellite tags near Maui as part of a Pacific Islands Ocean Observing System tracking study.

JAMM AQUINO / 2020 
                                Shark sightings are common in Hawaii, with signs posted to warn beachgoers. This one was put up at Kaimana Beach after several sharks were seen pursuing schooling baitfish about 20 yards from shore.
NATIONAL OCEANIC AND ATMOSPHERIC ADMINISTRATION
                                At top, tiger sharks are fitted with satellite tags near Maui as part of a Pacific Islands Ocean Observing System tracking study.

Humans have been afraid of sharks since long before “Jaws” and “The Meg” patrolled summer movie screens. Whether it’s the teeth or the lifeless eyes, something about them can just make your blood run cold.

Marine biologists are quick to say this fear is way out of proportion. Lightning strikes and bear attacks are more common than shark bites, they say. Of the more than 500 species of shark, only a handful have ever attacked humans, and most bites in the United States can be traced to just four species.

Even in Hawaii, which has the highest number of recent shark-related deaths, you are at least 130 times more likely to drown than die by a shark. There were 36 unprovoked shark attacks in the United States in 2023, according to the Florida Museum of Natural History; they caused two deaths.

But risk is a funny thing, and knowing the numbers rarely makes you feel better — especially after watching “Sharknado.” So what can you do to make your chance of a shark attack even smaller?

The answer depends on a few factors, starting with where you are and what month it is.

For example, Hawaii, which leads the country in fatal attacks, sees one about every other year, and the risk of bites more than doubles in October. Conversely, only two shark bites have ever been recorded in Washington state.

The most dangerous state

Hawaii is probably the most dangerous state for shark attacks. While it has the second-highest number of recorded bites, many have been serious. In 2023, for instance, it saw half as many bites as Florida, but one was deadly. This year Hawaii had a fatal attack in June.

An unusually high number of bites occur in October, which is likely related to the fact that pregnant tiger sharks congregate close to shore. Fortunately, that is a shoulder season, when the beaches are less crowded than in winter and summer.

Most serious attacks involve tiger sharks, but blacktips and great whites do swim off Hawaii shores. Most encounters involve board sports like surfing, but snorkelers are at some risk, especially in murkier water. The island of Maui sees the largest number of attacks.

Florida has the highest number of shark bites in the country. In 2023 there were 16 unprovoked incidents recorded (44% of the national total) but no deaths. In fact, no one has died from a shark bite in Florida since 2010. While encounters can happen at any time of year, they start increasing in midspring and drop off in late fall, with September seeing the most bites.

Most attacks seem to come from smaller sharks, like blacktips, which rarely cause serious injury. The worst injuries come from bull sharks. The East Coast tends to see more encounters than the Gulf side, and Volusia County, home to Daytona Beach, has an especially high number.

California has few shark attacks — just two recorded in 2023, fewer than New York and the Carolinas. However, because its white sharks are so big, attacks are more often serious. Of the 100 or so injuries since 2000, about 10% have been fatal. The largest white sharks tend to congregate near the so-called Red Triangle, around the Bay Area, from the middle of summer to late autumn.

Shark-tracking studies indicate that white sharks often swim near popular beaches, but most of them avoid people. Recent years have seen more encounters with younger sharks, especially in the south near Los Angeles or San Diego, suggesting they might be less adept at telling seals from humans.

Along the Atlantic coast

North and South Carolina have seen several hundred bites over the decades, mostly recorded since 2000, though only one or two fatal attacks in the past 50 years. Georgia has had far fewer bites, and none since 2021. Most of the run-ins between sharks and people here are driven by warmer weather, which draws sharks up from Florida and people out to the beach.

This region doesn’t seem to be a gathering area for sharks in the way that California and Hawaii are — though, the area of North Carolina around Cape Fear does see some bites.

Blacktips are the most common culprits, but the more serious attacks appear to have been from tiger or bull sharks.

Seals and white sharks were once common along the northeastern coast of the United States. Hunting reduced seal populations — and the predators that feed on them — to dangerously low levels until marine mammals were nationally protected in 1972. As the seal population has rebounded, white sharks have returned.

Today, places like Cape Cod, Mass., see a healthy white shark population each summer. Recorded attacks so far have been rare, though one man died there in 2018, and another in Maine in 2020.

The eastern coast from Virginia to New York doesn’t see many shark attacks, despite having many popular beach towns. In the past 185 years there have been only 52 recorded attacks; one since 2000 has been fatal. In the more recent serious cases, bull sharks were most often implicated.

Fewer incidents elsewhere

Oregon and Washington see few shark attacks. In the past 185 years there have been only 30 recorded; one was fatal. White sharks occasionally wander up here, but they do not congregate and seem to steer clear of people.

Despite having the longest coastline in the country, Alaska has just one documented shark attack: aboard a research vessel from a thrashing salmon shark.

The Gulf Coast of Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi and Alabama sees few shark attacks. In the past 185 years there have been only 62 unprovoked incidents recorded. Ten were fatal, but the last death was in 1962, in Texas. Galveston, Texas, leads the region, partly because the wind tends to make the water murky and beach fishing can attract sharks.

Some activities riskier

The other factor that most puts you at risk for a shark bite is what you happen to be doing in the water.

Surfers are unquestionably the most at risk for shark bites. In the 2010s about three times as many people worldwide were attacked surfing and doing other board sports than swimming and wading.

Surfboards can be confusing to sharks. From below a surfer resembles a seal, and a dangling foot looks like a floundering fish. Moreover, sharks have a special ability to detect electrical currents to find prey, and a surfer sitting on a board can confuse them.

Surfers also tend to stay in the water for a long time. The countless hours they spend floating, waiting for waves, simply create more opportunities for a shark to mistake a surfer for lunch.

Swimming alone in open water is another higher-risk activity, though attacks can also occur while people are wading or walking in shallow water. Many sharks, even large ones, can patrol surprisingly shallow waters looking for fish.

In Hawaii and Florida, snorkelers have had a number of run-ins with sharks. Most of the serious encounters have been in Hawaii and involved tiger sharks.

Attacks on scuba divers are rare, but they do happen and are occasionally fatal. Many involve divers who are spearfishing or collecting other sea life. Sharks are often scavengers; it’s important to be aware of your surroundings if you’re carrying a dead ocean creature, especially after you surface. Do not dive alone, and if you see a potentially dangerous shark, try to keep an eye on it as you exit the water.

Fishing — from shore, on a boat or with a speargun — can increase your risk of an attack. Anytime you are carrying bait or dead fish on your body, the chances go up that a shark will take an interest.

It’s wise to fish with an experienced partner. If you are wading or swimming near popular fishing areas, you might be at higher risk.

Please don’t kiss the shark

The statistics in this article mostly refer to unprovoked bites. But there have been reports of shark attacks from people feeding, grabbing, petting, kicking, chasing and, in at least one case, kissing wild sharks. These types of attacks seem to be especially common among social media influencers.

Provoked attacks aren’t limited to coastal states, either. Kentucky managed to rack up 12 shark attacks in 2006 after the aquarium in Newport opened a shark petting exhibit. And, at the Boat and Sports Show in 1996 in St. Louis, an underwater performer was bitten by a confused nurse shark named Bob. In all those cases no one was seriously harmed.

Most shark attacks are quick: a sudden impact, and then the animal retreats. In the slim chance that a shark holds on, don’t think about which sensitive spot on them is best to strike; go for all of them. Eyes, gills, snout — anything you can find. Sharks want an easy meal, so struggle and cause as much pain to them as you can to get them to back off.

Sharks almost never attack humans twice, so focus on getting out of the water without panicking.

Many deaths from shark bites could be prevented with a little bit of preparation. Regular surfers might want to buy a marine tourniquet and take a wilderness first aid class. Some beaches now provide first aid kits for heavy bleeding. Familiarize yourself with their contents or carry one of your own, if you spend a lot of time in the water.

So, how dangerous are sharks?

The risk of being attacked by a shark is extremely small but not zero. In Volusia County, the shark bite capital of the world, you are twice as likely to be killed with a gun than injured by a shark.

Still, statistics like this are little comfort to families of those killed by sharks, and they might not put your mind at ease as you wade into the ocean. So here is what we can say: If a shark recognizes you as a human, the danger is almost nonexistent.

How do we know? Recent drone studies have found that white sharks swim much closer to humans, and much more often, than previously thought. In fact, if you are a surfer or regular swimmer, you have probably been near a large shark without knowing it.

Attacks are so rare because sharks are good at knowing what is food and what isn’t. And humans simply aren’t on their menu.

Some people will never be able to go into the ocean without worrying about sharks. But as you head to your favorite beach, remember this: You are entering their world. The reason you are safe is that they just don’t care about you.

HAWAII SHARK ENCOUNTERS

The state Department of Land and Natural Resources’ Division of Aquatic Resources lists four “shark incidents” so far this year, all in Oahu waters.

>> March 2, Kualoa Beach. A person swimming in turbid water about 5 to 10 feet from shore suffered lacerations when bitten on the left foot by a 3-foot shark of unknown species.

>> March 4, Old Man’s surf spot off Waikiki. An 8- to 10-foot tiger shark bit the tail of a surfer’s board in turbid water about 350 yards from shore.

>> June 7, Haleiwa. In what is considered a provoked incident, a person who was “swimming with sharks” about 3 miles from shore suffered lacerations to their right thigh, forearm and hand when bitten by a shark of unknown size and species.

>> June 23, Malaekahana. City ocean safety lifeguard and professional surfer Tamayo Perry, 49, was fatally mauled by a shark of unknown size and species while surfing in turbid waters.

TIGER SHARK

‘Garbage can of the sea’

>> Size: 10-18 feet

>> Feeding habits: Tiger sharks are among the ocean’s least picky eaters. They feed on fish, sea turtles, plastic bottles and the occasional license plate. They often hunt in murky water, but in clear water are generally unaggressive and curious.

>> Fun fact: Tiger sharks are known to congregate along bird migration routes and snack on exhausted songbirds crossing the Gulf of Mexico.

HOW TO AVOID AN ATTACK

There isn’t a shark on Earth that sees humans as a natural food source; almost every unprovoked attack is from mistaken identity. So the key to staying safe is making it clear you are not shark food. Because attacks are so rare, it’s hard to be sure how effective certain precautions are, but here are a few that experts suggest.

>> Stay in groups. Sharks are skittish, and a group of humans is more obviously not food than one person.

>> Be cautious mornings and evenings. Many sharks, especially younger white and tiger sharks, hunt at dawn and dusk, when low light makes it harder for them to see as clearly. There are also fewer people in the water at these times, and sharks are more likely to wander toward shore.

>> Stay away from shark food. Avoid seal colonies and schools of fish. When fish wander toward the shore or seals gather on the beach, sharks tend to follow. Many beach towns will monitor fish movements and shark sightings and post advisories if either come toward shore. If you see dolphins and birds feeding, assume a shark is in the water, too.

>> Watch what you wear. Don’t worry about the color of your bathing suit — sharks are mostly colorblind. But they do see contrast and are always looking for floundering fish, so it’s good to leave shiny jewelry (which can resemble a fish’s scaly underbelly) at home.

>> Don’t worry about an open wound. A common belief is that sharks are drawn to open wounds and even to menstrual blood. This isn’t true. Experts say sharks are no more interested in the blood of land mammals than a spilled can of soda. And they can certainly tell the difference between a dying seal and a cut on your leg.

>> Please don’t play with sharks. It shouldn’t need to be said, but sharks don’t like to have their tails pulled, nor do they like being kissed. Just … don’t.

———

New York Times


This article originally appeared in The New York Times.


© 2024 The New York Times Company

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Terms of Service. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. Report comments if you believe they do not follow our guidelines. Having trouble with comments? Learn more here.