Honolulu City Council advances Haleiwa expansion project
JAMM AQUINO / JUNE 27
A “Keep the Country Country” sign was displayed on a car’s dashboard at Sunset Beach on the North Shore.
A proposed Haleiwa housing and commercial development project that has sparked community opposition over the loss of agricultural land, increased traffic congestion and the high cost of living advanced Tuesday.
The Honolulu City Council voted 8-1, with Matt Weyer dissenting, in favor of Bill 37, related to Haleiwa Backyards LLC.
The planned project is on a more than 7.5-acre vacant parcel between Kamehameha Highway and Joseph P. Leong Highway, near Achiu Lane and Cane Haul and Emerson roads.
The development calls for up to 156 low-rise, two-bedroom rental units with an accompanying 30,000 square feet of office and retail space, parking, and a wastewater management system.
Basin Project Inc. — operated by D.G. “Andy” Anderson — is the property owner.
The developer says the rental units could include eight “affordable” two-bedroom units targeted for those who earn 80% of the area median income — for one person in 2025 that equates to earning $85,150 annually, state data indicates. As proposed, 146 units would be leased as market-rate rentals.
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with breaking news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It's FREE!
The eight two-bedroom units proposed for lease at 80% AMI would see a monthly rent of $2,500. The remaining units would have monthly rents of $2,800, the developer says.
With a mix of uses, the project would feature multifamily housing with a density of 20 units per acre and three stories not exceeding 40 feet in height, according to the developer’s consultant.
The project is deemed “gap housing” or “workforce housing” — usually considered “affordable” to middle-income earners — and “not solely as an affordable housing” project, the developer’s consultant states.
But the Council’s vote on a committee draft of Bill 37 — the second of three readings — does not advance the project itself.
Instead, it would allow for zoning changes for the proposed development site. The bulk of the project’s property — about 7.29 acres — is currently zoned agricultural.
Bill 37, if fully adopted, would amend the state Land Use District Boundary Map — for an area known as the Haleiwa Quadrangle — by reclassifying the 7.29 acres from its current state land use agricultural district to the state land use urban district, to allow for its development.
Bill 37 states the project will “contribute to the general welfare and prosperity of Oahu residents by allowing for the development of much needed low- to moderate-income housing in the Haleiwa Special District, particularly for Oahu residents who work in the nearby retail and commercial areas of Haleiwa.”
The measure further claims the project will “help address the city’s housing crisis by allowing for the development of decent, reasonably-priced housing with access to schools, services, amenities, and job opportunities.”
Haleiwa Backyards LLC has garnered community opposition, which featured nearly an hour’s worth of public testimony largely resistant to Bill 37.
At the same meeting, neither Anderson nor his consultant, Makena White, with Planning Solutions Inc., spoke on behalf of the development or Bill 37.
Among those opposed, Denise Antolini, a Pupukea resident, said “this is a discretionary decision on the part of the Council.”
“So you need to make those policy choices, and it’s essentially (agriculture) versus urban, to be honest,” she said, adding any district boundary amendment would be “irreversible.”
Zaz Dahlin, a North Shore resident, said the area’s agricultural history is in jeopardy.
“We should all be concerned about disappearing farmland, especially on the North Shore where the motto is ‘Keep the Country, Country’,” she added. “I stand firmly against rezoning ag land to urban commercial business for corporate greed and commercial profit.”
“The people do not want this project built, ever,” she said. “It’s the wrong place, wrong time, wrong community.”
She also noted the high cost of living has forced many to leave the state for other locales.
“Outside money is buying Hawaii and displacing Hawaiians and local, longtime residents,” Dahlin said. “…I do not know about you but I’m tired of seeing my friends and ohana leave, and moving off-island because they’re priced out of paradise.”
State Sen. Kurt Fevella, whose District 20 encompasses Ewa Beach, also appeared at the meeting to oppose Bill 37. He said the project would create more traffic congestion for the North Shore.
“How many of you guys really drive in Haleiwa when it’s not even a busy day? It takes me 20 minutes just to get from one point to the other,” he said. “And I rarely visit the area.”
He noted the “trials and tribulations” of the businesses there.
“Haleiwa has been stricken by having its plantation being closed down,” Fevella said. “We should not use a (zoning) change because people want homes and economic development that is not going to be sustainable for our state and city.”
However, Mark Anthony Clemente, with the Hawaii Regional Council of Carpenters, said his trade group was “in strong support of Bill 37.”
“You know we heard a lot about a majority of our food being imported but a majority of our people are also being exported,” he said. “And so a lot of that has to do with housing.”
“I mean, the state has 1.9 million acres of agriculturally-zoned lands. We’re talking about less than 8 acres that (are) being asked to be changed to ‘urban’,” he asserted. “We have about 5% of our lands that are zoned ‘urban.’”
Housing, he added, can be built on “4% of our lands.”
“So all these things, we just ask that you take into consideration when we talk about our out-migration of locals, our housing crisis and balancing those things,” Clemente said.
At the meeting, the city Department of Planning and Permitting also expressed provisional support for the legislation and the project.
Dina Wong, DPP’s chief planner, said her agency only processes state land use district boundary amendments that are 15 acres or less. “We get them very infrequently,” she added. “The last one we received was, I believe, in 2018 for BYU-Hawaii.”
Under Bill 37, Wong said for Haleiwa Backyards LLC to be developed in the city and county certain affordability requirements needed to be met.
“So under our affordable housing rules … you would need 30% of all the units to be affordable, and of those 10% would be to households earning 80% AMI and below, and then 20% need to be affordable to 120% AMI and below,” she said.
In 2025, a single person at 120% AMI earns $108,600 annually, state data indicates.
Still, Wong noted the zoning change could require “through a unilateral agreement, a greater amount of affordable units, lower AMI units, longer affordability periods.”
“So what actually emerges could be greater than the affordable housing rules,” she said.
She also noted one of the conditions of the current draft of Bill 37 “is for the applicant to update the traffic impact analysis report” for the project area.
“And to have it accepted by both the (state) Department of Transportation and DPP’s traffic review branch,” Wong said. “To have it accepted before they can even submit their zone change application” if that condition stays in the latest version of Bill 37.
Thomas Blair, a DPP staff planner, also noted that under the legislation the project applicant will have to commit to further community engagement over the project.
During Council discussion, Weyer – whose Council District 2 includes the North Shore – said the overall testimony against Bill 37 was “extremely compelling.” Due to this, he said it was his preference for the measure to be “deferred.”
“But if it was going to be put up for a vote today, I’d be voting ‘no,’” Weyer asserted.
After the meeting, Andrew Phomsouvanh, the Council’s spokesperson, confirmed Bill 37 will progress to a “special Zoning Committee” meeting.
“The meeting date is not known yet, but will be sometime in July,” he added.

