Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Saturday, November 21, 2026 79° Today's Paper


Maui vacation rental conversion bill passes initial vote

Andrew Gomes
STAR-ADVERTISER / 2023
                                A controversial bill to prohibit short-term vacation rental use in about 6,100 condominiums passed a first vote on Thursday. Pictured is the entrance to Honua Kai Resort & Spa in Lahaina, which has short-term rentals.

STAR-ADVERTISER / 2023

A controversial bill to prohibit short-term vacation rental use in about 6,100 condominiums passed a first vote on Thursday. Pictured is the entrance to Honua Kai Resort & Spa in Lahaina, which has short-term rentals.

A divided Maui County Council committee has approved a controversial bill to prohibit short-term vacation rental use in about 6,100 condominiums that may somewhat replenish housing inventory lost to wildfire nearly two years ago.

The initial approval of the bill with a few amendments was delivered by a 6-3 vote from the Housing and Land Use Committee on Thursday.

Because all council members are on the committee, upcoming readings and final approval of the bill proposed by Maui Mayor Richard Bissen may be perfunctory.

At Thursday’s meeting, there was much debate and some tweaking of the bill after seven prior all-day meetings since June 9.

Those earlier meetings included divided public testimony from over 300 people, a presentation from Bissen, a day of questioning officials in Bissen’s administration, and a day spent behind closed doors conferring with county attorneys on potential legal consequences from what some stake­holders construe as taking legal property rights without just compensation.

A University of Hawaii Economic Research Organization analysis also was published in April and estimated that the prohibition could push down condo prices by 25% to make them more affordable to many more residents, but also could result in 1,900 job losses, a $900 million drop in annual visitor spending and $60 million less property tax revenue on Maui.

One change made to Bill 9 on Thursday has the prohibition taking effect on Jan. 1, 2029, in West Maui and on Jan. 1, 2031, for the rest of the county.

Earlier proposed drafts of the bill had implementation dates of July 1, 2028, and July 1, 2030.

Council member Keani Rawlins-Fernandez thanked Bissen for taking bold action, and praised the Lahaina Strong community organization for efforts that she said helped government action reflect priorities of residents.

“This has been so tough, so emotional,” she said before voting in favor of the bill.

Rawlins-Fernandez called the bill a zoning “correction” that will have more residents living in areas designated for higher-density apartments.

Bill 9 targets condos on land zoned for apartment use that were built or approved before 1989, when hotels and vacation condos were permitted uses in Maui apartment districts.

The county amended its zoning code to bar such use in 1989, but grandfathered preexisting and approved units, which are mostly in West and South Maui and are often referred to as Minatoya List properties because then-Deputy Corporation Counsel Richard Minatoya recommended that the change not apply to units completed before March 5, 1991.

There were roughly 7,200 condo units on the list, but county officials excluded some from Bill 9 because they were approved as time-share properties, because they have zoning variances or for other reasons.

Council member Tamara Paltin said the bill’s big step toward being enacted sends a loud and clear message against real estate speculation and commodification. Paltin lives in West Maui, where an Aug. 8, 2023, wildfire killed 102 people and destroyed most of Lahaina, including about 5,500 homes including rental apartments.

“The concept that real estate is the wealth-builder is taking away from community,” she said. “It is taking away from all the things that make our communities great.”

Another advocate of the bill, council member Gabe Johnson, said government for too long prioritized profits over people.

“Well, the times are changing, brothers and sisters, I’m telling you,” he said. “It’s now time for people over profits.”

Shane Sinenci, another council member who voted for the bill, described it as a faster and more cost-effective way to increase Maui’s housing supply compared with new construction.

Council member Tom Cook said he wanted to support the bill and pursued several amendments, including one that would have exempted properties in the resort areas of Wailea, Kaanapali and Kapalua. Another Cook amendment pushed for an easier process for affected property owners to potentially obtain a zoning change from the council to allow continued vacation rental use.

“I’m very disappointed in the way this all evolved,” he said.

The two other members who voted against the bill in addition to Cook were Yuki Lei Sugimura and committee Chair Tasha Kama.

Two council members voted for the bill with reluctance.

Alice Lee, chair of the council, contended that the zoning change remedy available to affected condo owners is not reasonable because there could be too many applications to handle before the prohibition takes effect.

“What we’re doing is not a fair remedy,” she said.

Lee proposed an amendment to have the prohibition take effect whenever an affected condo is sold to another owner. Lee’s amendment was not considered after the committee spent about four hours behind closed doors conferring with county attorneys about legal ramifications of eight proposed amendments.

Lee supported the majority voting for the bill, but with reservations, and said the “half-baked” measure proposed by Bissen was not sufficiently improved in her view.

“We’re not coming out with clean solutions,” she said.

Council member Nohelani U‘u-Hodgins also voted for the bill reluctantly. “I do note and understand that we’re probably going to get sued, so best of luck to you folks,” she said, appearing to reference county attorneys. “And best of luck to us.”