Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Saturday, November 21, 2026 74° Today's Paper


YMCA of Honolulu requests city rezone of Atkinson property

GEORGE F. LEE / GLEE@STARADVERTISER.COM
                                The YMCA of Honolulu plans to sell its Central branch on Atkinson Drive.
1/3
Swipe or click to see more

GEORGE F. LEE / GLEE@STARADVERTISER.COM

The YMCA of Honolulu plans to sell its Central branch on Atkinson Drive.

GEORGE F. LEE / GLEE@STARADVERTISER.COM
                                According to the YMCA’s consultants, the Central Y is “is currently utilized as a recreation center and dormitory.” However the swimming pool has been closed to the public since 2015. The location also has a gymnasium and multipurpose areas.
2/3
Swipe or click to see more

GEORGE F. LEE / GLEE@STARADVERTISER.COM

According to the YMCA’s consultants, the Central Y is “is currently utilized as a recreation center and dormitory.” However the swimming pool has been closed to the public since 2015. The location also has a gymnasium and multipurpose areas.

GEORGE F. LEE / GLEE@STARADVERTISER.COM
                                The basketball court at the Central branch of the YMCA of Honolulu on Atkinson Drive.
3/3
Swipe or click to see more

GEORGE F. LEE / GLEE@STARADVERTISER.COM

The basketball court at the Central branch of the YMCA of Honolulu on Atkinson Drive.

GEORGE F. LEE / GLEE@STARADVERTISER.COM
                                The YMCA of Honolulu plans to sell its Central branch on Atkinson Drive.
GEORGE F. LEE / GLEE@STARADVERTISER.COM
                                According to the YMCA’s consultants, the Central Y is “is currently utilized as a recreation center and dormitory.” However the swimming pool has been closed to the public since 2015. The location also has a gymnasium and multipurpose areas.
GEORGE F. LEE / GLEE@STARADVERTISER.COM
                                The basketball court at the Central branch of the YMCA of Honolulu on Atkinson Drive.

The YMCA of Honolulu says it wants to sell its Central Y property near Waikiki, but only after the site is formally rezoned by the City & County of Honolulu.

Via its consultant R.M. Towill Corp., the Y submitted a written request to the city Department of Planning and Permitting in June involving the proposed change of the site’s city zoning at 401 Atkinson Drive, to allow for the height to be reduced from 350 feet to 150 feet.

Namely, the consultant’s letter asks for confirmation from DPP regarding the project’s need for environmental assessments or an amendment to the city’s Primary Urban Center Development Plan, or PUCDP — which encompasses areas from Kahala to Pearl City and is the most populous of the island’s eight planning areas.

The Y’s request also asserts any future rezone will allow it to more ably sell the 1.77-acre Atkinson site — valued at more than $21.14 million in the 2025 tax year, according to city real property assessment rec­ords — which it built in 1951.

An eventual sale of the Central Y is also expected to end the nonprofit’s years-long transitional housing program, located across the street from Ala Moana Center, as well as end the high cost to maintain the aging property, the consultant states.

The Y’s request follows a prior, opposite zoning change at the complex more than a decade ago — one that allowed the site’s building heights to go from 150 feet to 350 feet.

“In 2013, the project site was rezoned from A-2 Medium Density Apartment District with a 150-foot height limit to AMX-3 High-Density Apartment Mixed-Use District with a 350-foot height limit,” R.M. Towill project planner Isaiah Sato wrote in his June 26 letter to DPP. “Therefore the applicant proposes to revert the 2013 zone change and rezone the site from AMX-3, 350-foot height limit back to its original A-2, 150-foot height limit.”

The consultant also requests an existing unilateral agreement, or UA — conditions generally imposed by the city when land is rezoned — be terminated. Under a UA, if the rezoning is for housing, the landowner is typically required to set aside 30% of the homes to be rented or sold at below- market rates, DPP states.

Sato said that “rezoning the property back to an A-2 Medium-Density Apartment District and terminating the UA will restore development potential.”

“Its location within the (transit-oriented district) area provides opportunities for future developers to increase densification through the construction of affordable housing units and improvements to existing facilities like the swimming pool and gymnasium,” he wrote. “The property is within a half-mile radius (10-minute walking distance) of the site of the proposed Ala Moana rapid transit system station (located on Koa Street near the intersection of Kona Iki Street), Ala Moana Regional Park, and the shopping center itself.”

The consultant states the Central Y “is currently utilized as a recreation center and dormitory, and consists of an existing five-story rooming house with 115 dormitory units, a three-story multi-purpose building with ground floor parking, a swimming pool, a gymnasium, and multipurpose areas.”

Most of the health and fitness amenities at the Central Y — including its drained swimming pool — have been closed to the public since 2015.

The consultant’s letter notes the Y site “was up-zoned for a specific development being proposed by development partner, Aloha Kai Development.”

“However, after several years of negotiations, the agreement between the YMCA and Aloha Kai Development had been terminated,” Sato wrote. “The 2013 zone change contained project specific conditions based on the development being proposed by Aloha Kai Development.

“These conditions related to the number of units allowed, vehicle and pedestrian access, street frontage requirements, design guidelines, and affordable housing requirements,” Sato wrote. “Over the years the YMCA has received several inquiries to purchase the property; however, all of the potential development partners expressed concerns and have moved on because of the existing restrictions that were intended for the 2013 Aloha Kai Development project.”

R.M. Towill asserts that “terminating the UA will reestablish opportunities for future developers to improve ground-floor shade, facade transparency, wayfinding, and aesthetic appeal, enhancing pedestrian activity and community use of the property’s facilities.”

The consultant claims the property’s rezoning will not include any “significant” changes to the site — such as adding a wastewater treatment unit or a power- generating facility — and therefore does not require any studies like an environmental impact statement or an amendment to the PUCDP.

DPP confirmed its receipt of the Y’s written request.

“We are in the process of reviewing it and drafting a response,” Davis Pitner, a DPP public information officer, said.

If DPP accepts the Y’s requested zone change, the Honolulu Planning Commission could eventually hold public hearings on the matter. That panel’s decision could then lead to a recommendation to the Honolulu City Council for a bill for an ordinance to ultimately grant the city-level zone change.

During the May 27 Ala Moana-Kakaako Neighborhood Board meeting, Sato claimed the Central Y’s existing 5-story dormitory was occupied at about 75% capacity — or about 90 to 100 people.

At the meeting, the board’s Subdistrict 3 1st Vice Chair Jeanne Rice asked Sato if the Central Y would still be in that location.

“The Y is not seeking to develop the site,” Sato replied. “They want to down-zone it and sell it. A future development is not part of this zone change.”

Rice then asked YMCA of Honolulu’s former president and CEO Greg Waibel if his organization planned to move to a nearby location “to serve the community, which it has been for all these years?”

Waibel replied, “We do not have plans to continue operations, if and when (the branch) is sold to somebody else.”

Waibel — who’s since taken a job with the Chicago- based YMCA of the USA — also spoke to the Y providing transitional housing.

“About a third of our residents are kind of the ‘long-term people’ that have been there,” he said. “About a third are a little bit shorter term, and then others have a little bit more turnover.”

But Waibel claimed the Y’s “long-term strategy,” in Hawaii and across the nation, was to stop operating transitional housing facilities.

And as far as rezoning the Y is concerned, Sato said, “it could be anywhere from nine months to two years to get through the process.”

At the meeting, Ian Washburn, a member of Atkinson Neighborhood Community Association and a resident of the adjacent property, Sunset Towers at 419 Atkinson Drive, aired his concerns over this project.

“First of all, let’s establish the fact that none of the facilities at the Y have been operational since 2013 — that’s 12 years,” he told the board. “So it’s not a question of maintaining services or anything like that; there have been no services for 12 years.”

He said he hoped the YMCA would foster more public engagement over the site’s plans, alleging that about 2,000 area condominium owners within a 300-foot radius of the Central Y had not been properly notified about the requested rezone.

After the meeting, Washburn said he believed no legally required notifications had been sent to any neighboring properties along Atkinson Drive. “By law, they don’t have to notify each and every owner,” he added. “If they send it to the (Association of Apartment Owners) president it’s allowed.”

“I talked to the AOAO presidents” near the Central Y site, he said, “and nobody received anything.”

During the same neighborhood board’s meeting in July, Ben Sullivan, the Mayor’s Office of Climate Change chief resilience officer and executive director, told the panel such notices were sent to HOA boards “for those buildings adjacent to the Y.”

Sullivan added city law “does not require that the notices go to the individual unit owners, which can be a lot more onerous to find addresses and obtain.”

Washburn, a 17th-floor resident of Sunset Towers with a view of the Pacific Ocean, fears a 150-foot-tall building will eventually be built on the Y’s site in the future.

“If they pass this thing and build that tower, that will remove the million- dollar view from everyone from about the 15th floor in my building on down, so those people, their property value will plummet because they don’t have the view,” he added. “They’ll have some guy eating his Wheaties instead of the beautiful ocean.”

This week, Lisa Ontai, YMCA of Honolulu’s interim president and CEO, said no outside party has expressed interest in purchasing the Central Y property yet.

“Not to say that we won’t entertain any offers, but at this time you won’t see an active sales process going on right now,” she added. “If and when we do sell the property, proceeds from that are going to be reinvested into YMCA locations and community programs and services, where it’s going to really best meet the community’s needs.”

In response to allegations that no formal public notifications were sent to Atkinson area condo owners over this proposed rezoning project, Ontai noted R.M. Towill, as the Y’s contracted consultant, was responsible for handling such disclosures.

“We’re confident that we’ve followed all of the rules and regulations. And, if we haven’t, I’m sure we would have heard from the city and county Department of Planning and Permits,” she said. “Of course, if we had, we would have responded immediately.”