Questions over Lt. Gov. Sylvia Luke likely to inspire challengers
JAMM AQUINO / OCT. 30
Hawaii Lt. Gov. Sylvia Luke speaks to reporters at a Oct. 30 news conference.
Democratic and nonpartisan elected officials across the state are quietly calculating the financial and political costs of challenging Lt. Gov. Sylvia Luke by the June 2 filing deadline while suspicions swirl whether Luke is the target of an ongoing investigation by Hawaii’s attorney general.
“Believe me when I say they’re all thinking about it,” said one well-connected political insider who did not want to be identified. “It’s neighbor islanders, council members and mayors. Whoever is elected lieutenant governor this November, the political sky is wide open.”
Colin Moore, who teaches public policy at the University of Hawaii, said that as a result, “you can bet there are ambitious candidates who are having that conversation right now. That wouldn’t have happened last week. This is a small state without a lot of opportunities for statewide office that would put you in a position for Senate or governor. I guarantee there are a lot of people thinking about this.”
Several incumbent state legislators and Honolulu City Council members agreed with Moore’s assessment but declined to comment on the record about possibly meeting the June 2 deadline to formally declare they will challenge Luke in the Aug. 8 Democratic Party primary.
A number of state legislators, county council members and members of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs have gotten into plenty of legal and political trouble that led their constituents to vote them out of office.
But no elected officials or longtime political observers who spoke to the Honolulu Star-Advertiser could think of a sitting statewide Hawaii politician who has found themself in a situation like Luke has — and certainly not one that involves an investigation by the state Department of the Attorney General.
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with breaking news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It's FREE!
All 51 House seats are up for election in the Democratic and Republican primary elections, along with 13 of the 25 Senate seats. Subtracting Republican legislators, that still leaves 42 House Democrats and 22 Senate Democrats who could potentially challenge Luke in the August primary.
THE POSITION of lieutenant governor has few day-to-day, high-profile responsibilities, but it is a proven stepping stone to Congress or the Governor’s Office.
Former lieutenant governors George Ariyoshi, John Waihee, Ben Cayetano and Josh Green all went on to be elected governor. And both of Hawaii’s U.S. senators — Mazie Hirono and Brian Schatz — were former lieutenant governors.
Two weeks ago, the Green-Luke ticket appeared a near shoe-in for reelection, with no high-profile Democrat or Republican challenger in sight as yet.
“They looked formidable,” said Judith Wong, president of the League of Women Voters.
Political analyst Neal Milner said that leading up to the recent controversy, the incumbent ticket was considered “a sure thing for reelection.”
Now, with Luke’s reputation and political future in question, Milner said, “There are no lack of alternatives.”
Shirlene Ostrov, chair of the Republican Party of Hawaii, acknowledged there is no shortage of Democrats who might be willing to take on Luke were she to run for reelection.
“There would certainly be more than one candidate,” she said.
As for potential Republican candidates for both governor and lieutenant governor, Ostrov said, “We have been working on candidate recruitment for a couple of months. I would hope we have people who come forward.
“But I hope this one event is one event and they (Republicans) are running for values and ethical leadership,” Ostrov said. “We have been harping on ethical leadership long before Sylvia Luke.”
LUKE, THE former chair of the powerful House Finance Committee, told the Star-Advertiser Monday that she did not take a paper bag containing $35,000 in cash at a Jan. 20, 2022, dinner in front of Rep. Ty J.K. Cullen, who was serving as Finance Committee vice chair while working as an FBI informant.
But Luke acknowledged she may be the lawmaker whom federal prosecutors said Cullen recorded at the dinner with a lobbyist and his daughter.
Cullen was trying to get a lighter federal prison sentence before he and ex-state Senate Majority Leader J. Kalani English weeks later — in February 2022 — separately pleaded guilty to taking cash, casino chips, hotel rooms and other bribes between 2014 and 2021 from the late wastewater executive Milton J. Choy.
During their dinner in January 2022, Luke said, she accepted a $5,000 check from Cullen’s friend, Honolulu businessman Tobi J. Solidum, 66, and a $5,000 check from Solidum’s daughter, 33-year-old Kristen Pae.
Luke said she returned the checks in March 2022 after the guilty pleas by Cullen and English but never recorded them on her campaign spending reports due to “clerical oversight.”
On Friday, state Attorney General Anne E. Lopez announced that her office has issued “multiple subpoenas and completed several interviews” as part of its ongoing public corruption investigation after federal investigators informed her office that an “influential legislator” had been videotaped accepting $35,000 in a bag.
Lopez said she “cannot name names” and offered no timeline for when her investigation might reach a conclusion.
“The criminal investigation must be conducted methodically and carefully,” Lopez said at a news conference. “I assure the people of Hawaii we are taking this seriously. I ask for some patience.”
After the news conference, Luke would not say whether she had received a subpoena or was interviewed by state investigators.
RUNNING FOR lieutenant governor ahead of the June 2 filing deadline isn’t nearly the heavy lift required of an upstart, statewide gubernatorial or congressional campaign.
Candidates who are already raising money for the state Legislature, county council or mayors’ races can transfer their donations to run for lieutenant governor, according to Tony Baldomero, former associate director of the state Campaign Spending Commission.
Campaign donations, Baldomero said, can be used from “county to state or state to county” races, but cannot be transferred from county or state campaigns for use in elections for federal office.
Candidates for lieutenant governor run alone in the August party primaries. Voters then must choose between slates comprising the top gubernatorial vote-getter and the top lieutenant governor candidate from the same party.
Voters do not have the option in the November general election of picking a Republican lieutenant governor and a Democratic governor, or vice versa.
Kai Kahele, chair of the Office of Hawaiian Affairs, knows what it takes to move between Hawaii’s state, federal and nonpartisan political offices, since he was appointed by then-Gov. David Ige in 2016 to fill the Hilo Senate seat following the death of his father, Sen. Gil Kahele.
Kai Kahele then won his own race to retain the seat, was elected to Congress, ran unsuccessfully for governor against Green in 2022 but was elected to the OHA Board of Trustees, where the other trustees voted him as chair just over an hour after being sworn into office.
He insisted he has no interest in running for lieutenant governor but said the August Democratic primary could become crowded in a hurry.
“There’s no doubt” that Democrats and nonpartisan office holders across the state are considering the pros and cons of running, Kahele said.
“It is piquing the interest of many sitting state legislators, sitting mayors,” he said.
And in a nonpresidential election year, which typically attracts fewer voters, Kahele said the primary could see votes spread among multiple Democrats that could turn the race “into a wide-open field with a very narrow margin” to victory.
If the attorney general’s investigation remains unresolved, UH’s Moore said, Democratic and Republican challengers are sure to use the uncertainty surrounding Luke against her if she stays in the race.
“This will be a major talking point they’re going to bring up constantly,” he said. “For Luke, she could be entirely innocent of this. But it will still be a politically poison drip that’s really hard to get around. If she draws a strong challenger, it’s going to be even harder.”

