Pearl Harbor pollution trial against Navy begins
JAMM AQUINO/JAQUINO@STARADVERTISER.COM
The Empire State tanker ship is seen during a news conference Friday, Oct. 13, 2023, at Pearl Harbor in Honolulu. The vessel is part of the de-fueling operation of the Red Hill fuel facility that begins Monday, Oct. 16.
Opening statements in the case against the Navy alleging ongoing violations of the Clean Water Act began Tuesday, with the judge taking a motion for a partial judgment under consideration.
Wai Ola Alliance filed a lawsuit against the Navy in 2022, demanding the Navy close the Red Hill fuel storage facility and pay for past environmental violations tied to its fueling operations. In its most recent amended complaint, filed in June 2024, the citizen group alleged the Navy had significant ongoing violations of the Clean Water Act, Resource Conservation and Recovery Act and will continue to have such violations.
Despite the Red Hill facility being drained of fuel and closed, the groups alleged the Navy will continue discharging pollutants for sources at and near the facility into Pearl Harbor and the Halawa Stream, as well as contaminating the Southern Oahu Basal Aquifer.
The Navy has denied the allegations, claiming it has taken and will continue to take appropriate measures to ensure there is no current or reasonable likelihood of unpermitted pollutant discharges into water.
In court Tuesday, Wai Ola Alliance attorney Daniel Cooper said the case hinges on whether there is a continuing likelihood of intermittent or sporadic violations on or after the date of the original complaint filed, June 14, 2022. He claimed the Navy self-reported petroleum discharges as recent as 2024, and that the root causes of reported discharges in 2020, 2021 and 2024 have remained unchanged.
The key causes of the discharges, Cooper argued, was divided command and divided project tracking. He claimed command responsibilities for operations, inspection, maintenance, repairs and upgrades of fuel infrastructure were and still are split between at least five independent federal entities with separate command structures.
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with breaking news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It's FREE!
“As noted by Adm. (Christopher) Cavanaugh when investigating the causes of the Red Hill releases: When everyone is in charge, no one is in charge,” Cooper said.
When it came to project tracking, Cooper claimed project management for the Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam fueling infrastructure was and still is divided among at least seven databases and that the Navy lacked a centralized database to track, manage and confirm implementation of critical tasks.
“The outcome of this failed inspection, maintenance, repair and upgrade tracking is hundreds, if not thousands, of delayed, deferred or ignored maintenance and repair projects in the fueling infrastructure,” Cooper said, adding that the failed maintenance led to the 2020, 2021 and 2024 discharges.
Department of Justice attorney Alexander Pupuro argued that the Clean Water Act does not allow citizens to hold the government liable for past violations, adding that the discharges from active fuel lines in 2020 and 2021 both ended nearly a year before the lawsuit was filed. The Navy decommissioned one fuel line and is completely replacing another, Pupuro said, and both are also not being used until repairs are made.
Pupuro said the Clean Water Act is a specific cause of action that requires plaintiffs to prove there was an unauthorized discharge of pollutants from an identifiable source into navigable waters. He argued the claims in the lawsuit should only consider whether the alleged violations exist and have recurred or are likely to recur.
“It’s not meant to be a complete audit of the Navy’s operations,” he argued.
Pupuro claimed there was no evidence of ongoing discharges since the case was filed, and that if there were alleged pollutants found, the source of the contamination was unknown and cannot be traced to a specific Naval source.
The Navy also has removed more than 100 million gallons of fuel from Red Hill without incident, Pupuro said, the majority of which went through fuel lines at one of the locations where the discharges occurred.
Pupuro said the Navy implemented improved tracking, monitoring, compliance and training measures and complies with the Occupational Safety and Health Administration process safety management regulations.
“The Navy’s work to improve and maintain the facility continues to this day,” Pupuro said. ” A recurrence of discharges here is not reasonably likely.”
Petroleum corrosion and project management expert William Rogers, called by Wai Ola Alliance, testified that while a report showed that most of the pipes on Joint Base Pearl Harbor-Hickam had hundreds of years of service left, with the worst pipes still having 41 years of service left, the corrosion evaluated was “uniform corrosion” over a large surface area. The problems, he said, were “localized pit corrosion,” or single points of highly accelerated corrosion.
Excessive corrosion can lead to leaks or broken pipes, Rogers said.
Rogers testified that during his visit to the base in September 2024, he saw corrosion similar to a system that would have been abandoned or retired.
“I’ve never seen anything like this in an active site,” he said.
Photos from Rogers’ visit to the base and shown in court depicted heavily corroded pipelines underneath piers and above seawater, though it was unclear whether those pipes had active fuel in them at the time the photos were taken.
During his visit, Rogers said he did not visit an underground pump station or a key allegedly broken valve, which the Department of Justice identified as critical points of infrastructure that should have been evaluated.
He added that united command does not necessarily mean one person or entity is in charge of everything, but rather that the person or entity has the tools and an effective communication plan to ensure projects stay on schedule. The lack of a united command virtually guarantees leaks will continue to happen, he said.
Wai Ola Alliance rested its case after Rogers’ testimony, to which the Department of Justice made an oral motion for a partial summary judgment, claiming the group had not met its burden of proof. U.S. District Court Judge Leslie Kobayashi said she will make a decision on the motion once evidence in the case is completed.
Guy Pasco, supervisory general engineer of the facilities division in the Pearl Harbor fuel department, testifying on behalf of the Navy, said there were three databases that separate tracked actions, compliance and inventory of petroleum assets and infrastructure. The petroleum asset database tracks time-based maintenance of infrastructure, he added.
Pasco said he has weekly staff meetings where various projects are discussed. He said while databases are not reviewed, the fuels director gives PowerPoint presentations on project progress.
Pasco’s testimony is expected to finish when court resumes today at 12:30 p.m.

