Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Friday, November 20, 2026 80° Today's Paper


West Oahu hillside eyed for new city landfill

GEORGE F. LEE / JAN. 13
                                Pictured at top is the Waimanalo Gulch Sanitary Landfill in Kapolei, which is expected to close in 2028.
1/2
Swipe or click to see more

GEORGE F. LEE / JAN. 13

Pictured at top is the Waimanalo Gulch Sanitary Landfill in Kapolei, which is expected to close in 2028.

STAR-ADVERTISER
                                <strong>Kurt Fevella: </strong>
                                <em>The state senator from Ewa Beach said area legislators found out about the city’s proposed landfill at Makaiwa Hills because of a neighborhood board meeting </em>
2/2
Swipe or click to see more

STAR-ADVERTISER

Kurt Fevella:

The state senator from Ewa Beach said area legislators found out about the city’s proposed landfill at Makaiwa Hills because of a neighborhood board meeting

GEORGE F. LEE / JAN. 13
                                Pictured at top is the Waimanalo Gulch Sanitary Landfill in Kapolei, which is expected to close in 2028.
STAR-ADVERTISER
                                <strong>Kurt Fevella: </strong>
                                <em>The state senator from Ewa Beach said area legislators found out about the city’s proposed landfill at Makaiwa Hills because of a neighborhood board meeting </em>

A West Oahu hillside envisioned for a 4,300-home development that overlooks the Pacific Ocean and Ko Olina Resort is now being eyed for the island’s next municipal solid waste landfill, city officials say.

The proposed dump site, known as Makaiwa Hills, spans roughly 150 acres and is owned by James Campbell Company LLC. It sits adjacent to the city’s 37-year-old Waimanalo Gulch Sanitary Landfill in Kapolei, which is scheduled to close by March 2, 2028.

Honolulu Mayor Rick Blangiardi’s administration has earmarked $30 million in next fiscal year’s proposed $5.08 billion city budget package to acquire land for the new dump.

“It will likely take years to obtain necessary permits and to construct, with a possible operational date of 2033,” said Ian Scheuring, deputy communications director for the mayor’s office.

He said the total cost to build a new landfill is estimated at $190 million, adding “the city and Campbell have been involved in conversations surrounding the property since November 2025.”

“At this time, the city declines to comment further on those conversations,” Scheuring said.

In a written statement, Campbell says it’s “aware of the City &County of Honolulu’s interest in Makaiwa Hills as a potential significant expansion of the Waimanalo Gulch landfill site.

“The site is entitled for housing, and we have always intended for Makaiwa Hills to supply additional housing on the West Side,” the company said. “We understand the importance of land-use decisions by the city to solve community needs and will remain open to continued dialogue with the City &County.”

According to the company’s website, Makaiwa Hills is bounded by Farrington Highway, Kapolei West and Ko Olina Resort to the south; Makakilo to the east; Palehua Road and agricultural lands to the north; and Waimanalo Gulch to the west.

“It is the last coastal hillside residential area planned on the island, providing a unique long-term development opportunity,” the company states.

First envisioned in the 1970s, the project is part of the Kapolei Area Long Range Master Plan, and includes plans for both an elementary and a middle school, the company said. In 2008, the city approved zoning changes to allow residential and mixed-use development.

Since that time, the city said no approved development project has materialized on that property.

The Blangiardi administration’s desire to obtain a new landfill site followed its 2024 decision, which sought to locate a garbage dump on Dole Food Co. agricultural property near Wahiawa.

But by 2025 the state Legislature blocked the city’s landfill on an active pineapple field by passing a new law — Act 255 — which made it illegal to build garbage dumps over prime agricultural lands and freshwater aquifers in Hawaii.

City officials say they also seek changes to Act 73, a 2020 state law that restricts landfill placement near conservation lands or half-mile “buffer zones” near residential areas, schools, hospitals, airports and tsunami zones.

Officials say potential Act 73 amendments could reduce those buffer zones to a quarter-mile or possibly eliminate them altogether, thereby opening up more land for potential city dump sites. Such a legislative change could take time, however.

During a packed April 22 Makakilo-Kapolei-Honokai Hale Neighborhood Board meeting, city Department of Environmental Services Program Administrator Josh Nagashima said the first step in acquiring the Makaiwa Hills site included submitting a Public Infrastructure Map application, or PIM, with the city Department of Planning and Permitting for review.

The PIM designates properties for development and use with city funding. “And if the PIM goes through next fiscal year, which starts July 1, we’re hoping to acquire the land,” he said. “So we’ve already talked to Campbell…We look to negotiate on that, and if not, we may have to go through the condemnation process.”

The new landfill would also require an environmental impact statement, along with solid waste and air pollution control permits from the state Department of Health, among other approvals, the city said. A 30-day public comment period on the project’s PIM is currently underway, with review by the Honolulu City Council scheduled for May and June.

Due to the lengthy timeline, officials say the existing Waimanalo Gulch landfill may need to remain in operation until 2031.

“Potentially, we could be shipping (solid waste) off-island during that time, or we could be making a temporary landfill site where we would put waste for now, and then we would move it into the landfill when it’s open,” Nagashima said.

But Neighborhood Board member Carol England questioned the logic of dumping waste short term. “If you’re going to build a temporary landfill, why not just make that the permanent landfill?” she asked.

ENV Director Roger Babcock said temporary sites are designed differently.

“They create an actual landfill with a liner and all of the other protections that are part of a landfill, but it’s not meant to be permanent,” Babcock said. “So presumably then it could be located somewhere where a permanent landfill is not allowed.

“But it would be temporary; it would be there for a couple of years until the new landfill is operational,” he added. “Then, like on Maui, all of the material that had been placed there would be moved to the new landfill.”

West Oahu residents who oppose the new landfill say the mayor broke his promise.

They also assert the west side is being unfairly burdened with yet another landfill in West Oahu, and denounce the lingering health, environmental and quality-of-life impacts that landfills can bring to the largely Native Hawaiian communities living in the area.

Council Vice Chair Andria Tupola — whose Council District 1 encompasses the Leeward Coast — asked “what committee of people decided” that a new landfill should be at Makaiwa Hills.

Babcock said that decision came from within the city administration.

State Rep. Diamond Garcia (R, Ewa-Kapolei) questioned whether the city had, in fact, approached the state Legislature over amending Act 73 to potentially open up more sites for a landfill on Oahu.

“From what I’ve heard there was no conversation with legislators,” Garcia said. “I just asked my colleagues who represent this area and myself. Nobody came to us asking for amendments to Act 73 — this session, last session, the previous session — to ensure that promises were kept, because we were told that no more landfills would be in West Oahu.”

Garcia questioned which city officials spoke with the Legislature to amend Act 73.

Babcock replied, “The answer is, I don’t know who was consulted. That wasn’t something on my task list.”

State Sen. Kurt Fevella (R, Ewa Beach) asserted the Blangiardi administration “is lying to us.”And he added the proposed Makaiwa Hills residential community was supposed to have “houses in that valley, for our people, whose suffering.

“The mayor does not care, don’t let him fool you,” Fevella said. “He told me straight to my face, ‘No more landfills on your side of the island.’”

“Did he call any one of us to tell us that they made a decision to change it?” he asked.

Fevella said area legislators only became aware of the city’s proposed landfill at Makaiwa Hills because of the neighborhood board meeting. “If it wasn’t for this meeting, none of us would be here. We didn’t know,” he said.

In related business, the same board approved a draft resolution, which calls on the mayor to keep his promise and not build a new landfill in West Oahu.

The Mayor’s Office acknowledged the community frustration.

But “Oahu must have an operational landfill, and there is currently no realistic pathway forward that does not involve the construction of a new landfill,” Scheuring said.

Natural disasters highlight the urgency, he added.

“In the event that Oahu were to suffer a direct hit by a significant hurricane, for example, the volume of debris generated by that storm would overwhelm any available waste-to-energy facility, and in order to keep recovery operations moving forward, that debris would need to be taken someplace,” he said.

“Mayor Blangiardi has said repeatedly, for years, that he was opposed to the siting of another landfill in West Oahu, and his opinion has not changed,” Scheuring said. “What has changed, however, are the laws which dictate where the city can and cannot site a new landfill, leaving the city with no other options to consider at this time.”