Column: Hawaii takes another legal step toward climate justice
Did you know that Big Oil has been raking in an additional $30 million per hour in profits due to sky high oil prices since the Strait of Hormuz closed? Some of those windfall profits may ultimately find their way to pay for the massive climate damages we’ve had to weather here in the islands.
Last week, a Hawaii Circuit Court judge rejected Big Oil’s request to delay Honolulu’s pioneering climate lawsuit. The decision is important because it suggests Big Oil may finally face a legal reckoning for its role in dangerously deceiving us about the climate crisis — not just in Hawaii, but across the United States.
The islands face eroded beaches, intense wildfires and catastrophic storms — driven by fossil fuel pollution. That’s why Honolulu has led a growing number of state and local governments across the country seeking to hold the oil and gas industry accountable for harms they understood in detail, predicted with great accuracy, and lied to the public about.
The core claim in the lawsuits is straightforward: The oil and gas industry deceptively marketed and sold products they knew were dangerous, while lying to customers about these risks. This pattern of misbehavior allowed business as usual for decades while making billions of dollars in profits. It is only fair that the companies bear at least some of the costs coming due for state and local governments — and all of us by extension — including cleaning up after storms or wildfires and building stronger wastewater systems or cooler classrooms.
State courts, like the one hearing Honolulu’s case, have handled deceptive corporate claims like these for decades.
Just like big tobacco and pharma, oil companies are trying every trick in the book to delay these lawsuits or block them altogether. Their latest scheme is to argue that the cases should be “preempted” by federal law.
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with breaking news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It's FREE!
Industry recently succeeded in convincing the U.S. Supreme Court to intervene in a case called Suncor v. Boulder County, hoping to find a sympathetic audience for this argument among the high court’s conservative members.
The oil corporation defendants in the Honolulu case sought to take advantage of this development, requesting that the judge delay proceedings until the Supreme Court reaches a decision in Suncor. Rightfully, Judge Lisa Cataldo denied this request.
As Cataldo explained, the delay would cause significant harm, particularly given it will likely take several years before the case is finally resolved even in the absence of additional delay. Our Hawaii Supreme Court had already concluded that federal law did not preempt claims like that in the Honolulu case. This is a case about product deception and local damages here in Hawaii, and it isn’t clear that the Suncor case has merit.
This last point is worth emphasizing. The oil industry’s preemption argument in Suncor rests on very shaky ground. Several state courts that considered this question, including Hawaii, have quickly rejected it. Even the U.S. Supreme Court seems to recognize the frailty of industry’s case; when they accepted the appeal, the justices also asked the parties to offer arguments about whether the court has the authority to hear the case in the first place. A finding that it lacked jurisdiction over the case would prevent the court from reaching the preemption question at all.
The reality is that the impacts of climate change are piling up for Oahu and Hawaii. The question is who should help pay. A win for Honolulu would mean that the companies whose reckless behavior increased these damages will be on the hook for at least part of the cost. Principles of justice would demand nothing less.
Maxine Burkett is a former law professor at the William S. Richardson School of Law, University of Hawaii-Manoa.

