Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Saturday, November 21, 2026 74° Today's Paper


Column: Renegotiate wastewater plant upgrade

A recent commentary writer admirably advocates efficient implementation of the $2.5 billion Sand Island Wastewater Treatment Plant (SIWWTP) upgrade (“Take smart steps to treat wastewater,” Star-Advertiser, Island Voices, July 7). His detailed points, however, should not be taken as gospel, as a holistic science-based viewpoint tells a different story.

Over 40 years of monitoring proves that SIWWTP’s existing primary treatment is effective, and the secondary treatment upgrade is unnecessary. Primary treatment removes settleable solids and floating matter. Secondary treatment provides added removal of organic matter, pathogens, nutrients, and some toxic substances.

Based on sewage’s “yucky” image, upgrading treatment would seem plausible. In SIWWTP’s case, however, no tangible water quality or public health benefits would be realized. There instead would be adverse environmental and financial impacts.

Organic matter decomposes naturally in deep offshore waters so less treatment is needed. Wastewater nutrients in offshore waters support CO2-consuming phytoplankton that helps fisheries. Secondary treatment acts as a “CO2 factory” by converting organic carbon into detrimental atmospheric CO2. Ocean discharges have reduced risks due to pathogen die-off from exposure to saltwater and sunlight.

Secondary treatment makes sense when discharging to rivers and lakes. In confined water bodies, ammonia in wastewater is toxic to aquatic life. Microbial biodegradation of organic matter and ammonia depletes life- sustaining oxygen. Excessive nutrients promote eutrophication that also depletes oxygen. Mainland cities use inland surface water as a potable water source. SIWWTP’s deep ocean discharge has none of these issues.

In addition to the $2.5 billion construction cost, annual operation and maintenance can be expected to cost $50 million or more. Hawaii has struggled to maintain its mechanized treatment facilities due to corrosive conditions and shortage of skilled operations and support staff.

While secondary treatment removes some toxic “forever” chemicals, these chemicals do not magically disappear. They end up in the residual sludge. HPOWER lacks consistent high temperatures to reliably destroy these chemicals, and landfilling has its own challenges.

With ocean discharges, forever chemicals are removed from the food web when dead marine life that uptake the constituents sink to the ocean floor. In deep cold marine waters, vertical mixing is minimal and toxic constituents are effectively sequestered for thousands of years.

Banned ground termite treatment chemicals in the SIWWTP wastewater is not a significant concern. Discharge limits are typically based on eating relatively high amounts of contaminated fish on a regular basis. Consumption of seafood from waters near the SIWWTP outfall is very low, and testing of fishes near the discharge has routinely shown non-detectable pesticide levels.

Termite pesticides in our wastewater are likely from contaminated soil entering old corroding cast-iron home sewer pipes. The solution is to fix these lines. This would also help reduce infiltration of stormwater that causes sewer overflows.

The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) denied Honolulu’s waiver from secondary treatment in 2009 on dubious grounds, such as biased analysis of ammonia data, questionable toxicity testing procedures, correctable pesticide issues, and suspect ocean current models.

EPA understandably prefers not to issue Clean Water Act waivers due to the need to evaluate voluminous data, conduct hearings, and contend with lawsuits from environmental groups. To keep in the good graces of EPA and environmental groups, local officials and regulators put up no resistance. Consultants and contractors benefit from the huge volume of work generated. The lowly ratepayers suffer financially without any benefits. Use funds instead for watershed protection, flood control, and coral restoration projects with real benefits!

Renegotiating the federal consent decree is possible with support from key stakeholders. San Diego did this by having environmental groups agree to implementing water recycling in lieu of secondary treatment. We need a similar win-win outcome.


Roy K. Abe, P.E., is a retired professional civil engineer and former sanitary engineering consultant.