Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Thursday, November 19, 2026 73° Today's Paper


Column: AI belongs in education, just not everywhere

Artificial intelligence (AI) has become the student everyone loves to hate. As AI becomes a bigger part of our lives, it has raised the question: What is AI’s place in education? Many educators strongly oppose student use of AI. Their concerns are reasonable, as a majority of high schoolers and college students admit to using AI for schoolwork, which can detract from the learning experience.

Consistent use of AI leads to cognitive debt, the long-term loss of independent thinking. An MIT study found that AI reduces cognitive engagement and the ability to transform information into knowledge. But if AI makes us worse thinkers by replacing our modes of thinking, can it also make us better learners when we use it to discover new ways of thinking?

I would argue that knowing how to use AI is an essential life skill. As one teacher expressed, “We need to understand the power of AI along with its concerns so that we can make informed decisions about when to use AI and when to only use our own minds.”

My experience with AI has shown me that it does not always replace learning.

When preparing for a test, I use AI to generate extra review problems. When I’m struggling with a concept, I ask AI to explain it in different ways until it clicks. I still must solve problems and understand concepts myself, but AI gives me another way to learn when my teacher isn’t available.

Although AI has proven useful to me in STEM fields, it has a more limited purpose in the humanities or in writing. Unlike math or science, it becomes harder to generate review problems because there isn’t just one answer.

If I ask AI to help me rewrite something, it will do it for me, taking away the skills that I can only develop through actually doing the work. Because the humanities rely more heavily on creativity, AI poses greater risks, as it can prevent people from developing their own interpretations and ideas. For these reasons, I use AI less when writing.

However, AI can be helpful with the more mundane side of writing, such as spelling and grammar. Several of my peers use Grammarly to detect grammar errors.

AI use is not limited to students: 68% of K-12 educators and 61% of higher education educators use AI in class at least occasionally.

One teacher said, “My biggest use of AI is coming up with notes on the day’s lesson for students who need extra guidance or who missed class.” He said AI saved him at least a couple of hours a week, and with this extra time, he could give more attention to students. However, he believes grading, report card comments, and student-facing tasks should never be replaced by AI.

These teachers’ views reflect my own: I don’t believe AI should replace education. Only teachers can build the human connection and real-time emotional insight to truly understand a student’s needs. AI should be used for rote aspects of education, such as generating practice problems, but measures should be taken to protect real learning by restricting how AI is used in the classroom.

That is why I do not think AI in education is a simple yes-or-no question. The question should be how schools can educate students on responsible AI use and how teachers can use it to make learning more effective, not easier. Maybe the real threat to education is not AI itself, but failing to learn how to use it.


Chloe Yang is a student at ‘Iolani School, Class of 2027.

“Raise Your Hand,” a monthly column featuring Hawaii’s youth and their perspectives, appears in the Insight section on the first Sunday of each month. It is facilitated by the Center for Tomorrow’s Leaders.