Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Wednesday, November 18, 2026 79° Today's Paper


Honolulu City Council mulls curbs on taxpayer-funded election-year mailers

STAR-ADVERTISER
                                Tommy Waters seeks to ban use of city resources to distribute mailers 60 days before an election.

STAR-ADVERTISER

Tommy Waters seeks to ban use of city resources to distribute mailers 60 days before an election.

The Honolulu City Council is considering new restrictions on elected officials’ use of taxpayer-funded resources for mass communications, including mailers sent to voters near election dates.

The action comes amid a parallel effort by the city Ethics Commission to address concerns about incumbent Council members using public resources to promote their work shortly before voters head to the polls.

The commission’s interest intensified after Council Chair Tommy Waters issued a taxpayer-funded, four-page mailer in early June, weeks before the Aug. 8 primary election.

The mailer, which featured a photograph of Waters standing next to a Honolulu Police Department officer and highlighted the ways the chair was “working for you,” was sent while he was actively campaigning for a third consecutive term representing East Honolulu’s Council District 4.

Waters’ reelection bid, however, was stymied by a months-long legal fight brought by his chief challenger, Trevor Ozawa, over Waters’ eligibility to seek another term.

That litigation ultimately led to a 3-2 Hawaii Supreme Court ruling Aug. 28 that disqualified Waters from the election and ordered Ozawa and Tara Malia Gregory, the two eligible candidates who received the most votes in the primary, to advance to the Nov. 3 general election in the district stretching from Hawaii Kai to Waikiki.

In the aftermath, Waters on Sept. 17 introduced Resolution 210, which would add a new Rule 37 to the Council’s rules prohibiting Council members who are candidates for federal, state or local office from using city resources to distribute mass communications during the 60 days immediately preceding an election.

The proposed rule would prohibit a Council member from using city resources to mail or otherwise distribute substantially identical communications to 200 or more people. It would apply to regular, special and runoff primary and general elections.

The resolution broadly defines “city resources” to include “any property or asset owned by the city,” including money, facilities, equipment, supplies, postage, electronic mail, letterhead, a Council member’s official title and city-compensated personnel time.

The proposed restrictions would not apply to direct responses to individual inquiries, communications to federal, state or city government officials, news releases distributed directly to the media, emergency or disaster notifications involving immediate threats to life and safety, or communications required by law.

Council members also would remain free to distribute mass communications using private resources, including email, websites, social media, text messages and recorded telephone messages or robocalls, as long as city resources are not used.

“I introduced this amendment because taxpayer­-funded constituent communications should never be used, or appear to be used, for campaign purposes,” Waters said in a written statement.

Waters said he has followed a 60-day blackout practice throughout his public service, including when the Council did not formally require one.

“With the issue now under public discussion and the Ethics Commission considering a similar policy, I believe the Council should act now,” Waters said. “This amendment establishes a clear, consistent rule for every member and reinforces the line between public serv­ice and campaigning.”

The two candidates who will face off in November for the District 4 seat offered differing views on Waters’ proposal.

“The first question I ask when the government proposes a new rule is: How does this benefit the people?” Gregory said via email.

She added that she supports separating public and campaign resources but wants more information before supporting the resolution. But she also questioned the need to adopt the rule before the Nov. 3 election.

“If there is an urgent need to change the rules during an election already underway, what is that urgency?,” Gregory said. “Why must this take effect now rather than prospectively?”

Ozawa said he supports the basic concept behind Waters’ proposal, but believes the rule should distinguish between campaign- style communications and routine constituent services.

“Voters can tell the difference between an office keeping them informed and a piece that’s really about the person who sent it, and they should hold us to that,” Ozawa added.

During a special meeting of the Council’s Executive Management Committee on Sept. 23, Waters expanded on his reasons for introducing Resolution 210 — the only item on the hearing’s agenda.

“Its purpose is straightforward … to ensure that the public resources are never used, or perceived to be used, to provide an electoral advantage to an incumbent,” Waters said. “At present, Honolulu has no Council rule specifically governing taxpayer-funded mass communications in an election year.”

He noted that other legislative bodies, including the state House of Representatives, have “long observed a 60-day election blackout practice.”

“I have followed that practice throughout my public service, including during my time on the Council,” Waters said. “Even when it was not formally required here, because I believe it is important to safeguard the public trust.”

During public testimony, Honolulu Ethics Commission Executive Director and Legal Counsel Sandy Ma offered comments on the proposal, emphasizing the commission itself had not taken a position on this matter.

Ma raised several questions about the proposed rule, including its 200-­person threshold. She noted that the federal threshold is 500 recipients.

“The area covered by federal distribution and their constituents are much greater, and the area here is 200, so that is just a comment,” she said.

Ma also questioned whether the proposed rule could be circumvented through what she called “serial distribution” of communications. “You could send out 200, and then another 200, then another 200, and then the blackout date kicks in,” she said.

Ma also recommended the Council consult the City Clerk’s Office before pursuing this resolution.

“We are an all-vote-by-mail state,” she said. “And the 60 days time period should be consistent with sending out the vote-by-mail ballots.”

Council member Scott Nishimoto subsequently asked whether Ma was offering her “personal” views on this legislation.

Ma replied that she was speaking on behalf of the Ethics Commission staff, not the commission itself.

Waters also asked Ma about the state Legislature’s rules governing mass communications during election periods.

Ma said the state House adopted a blackout rule that took effect June 3 and runs through Nov. 4. But Ma declined to answer subsequent questions from Waters concerning election matters, saying she could not speak for the City Clerk’s Office.

“I’m here for the Ethics Commission staff,” she said.

Waters eventually recommended the committee defer Resolution 210 for further review.

Council member Esther Kiaʻaina also requested the Council consult the City Clerk’s Office before proceeding with the measure.

Waters agreed, adding he wanted to ensure the rule “only applies to people who are running for election or reelection, as the case may be.”

Before Wednesday’s meeting, Ma told the Honolulu Star-Advertiser that the Ethics Commission had been concerned about Waters’ July mailer, which may have “implicated” City Charter Section 11-104, Fair and Equal Treatment, “in which officers and employees shall not use their official position to secure for themselves special treatment, advantage, or privilege beyond what is available to everyone else.”

“So what that means is an incumbent should not be using city resources to help for reelection because (an unelected) person running for office will not be able to use city resources for their campaign,” she said.

Ma stressed the Ethics Commission is “not part of this resolution.”

She said the commission’s staff discussed the issue internally, and could submit additional information on the proposal, although that might not be necessary if the Council adopts its own restrictions soon.

Still, Ma noted the Ethics Commission is expected to review Resolution 210 at its Oct. 21 meeting.

“Certainly, it will be presented to the commission,” she said.

Correction: >> Honolulu City Council Chair Tommy Waters sent a taxpayer-funded, four-page mailer in early June, not in early July, as was reported in an earlier version of this story.