UH study finds higher metal levels in Maui wildfire survivors
MAX WHITTAKER / THE NEW YORK TIMES
The charred remains of Lahaina, a coastal town on the Hawaiian island of Maui, Aug. 11, 2023.
Maui wildfire survivors had higher concentrations of metals in their systems months after their exposure to the fires in 2023, according to a study by the University of Hawaii.
UH-Manoa’s Maui Wildfire Exposure Study tracked 1,400 Maui adults from a period of six to 18 months after the historic tragedy that razed Lahaina town due to concerns about their exposure to environmental toxins.
Researchers measured 24 metals from urine samples alongside standardized breathing tests to assess pulmonary function during the same visit.
Compared with publicly available data from the U.S., researchers found Maui participants had markedly higher concentrations of several metals, including antimony, manganese, barium, and arsenic. Antimony was highest, at nearly 40 times the U.S. reference value.
The findings were recently published in the “Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.”
“Our study suggests that months after the fires, many residents were still carrying elevated mixtures of metals in their bodies, meaning that exposure did not necessarily end when the smoke cleared,” said Alika Maunakea, MauiWES co-director, in a news release. “Urban wildfires can create a much longer lasting contamination problem involving ash, dust, soil, debris, homes, cars, and other burned materials.”
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with breaking news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It's FREE!
When an entire community burns, he added, there is a much more complicated exposure environment.
“The biology is telling us that we need to understand not only what was in the air during the fire,” he said in the release, “but what was already present in the landscape, what the disaster may have mobilized, and what is actually getting into people’s bodies during the months and years that follow.”
Researchers were also able to associate these higher levels of combined metals with abnormal lung function. They found arsenic, cadmium, copper and antimony to be among the metals that contributed most strongly to those associations.
They emphasized that the elevated metal levels likely reflect a complex mixture of exposures rather than a single source.
Some of these exposures may have existed before the wildfire due to diet, other environmental factors, agricultural and industrial land use of the area, and Hawaii’s geology.
The wildfire disaster may have introduced new contaminants, researchers noted, while also “disturbing and remobilizing pollutants already present in soil, dust and the built environment.”
Researchers hope to examine this in further depth as part of a new study investigating pollutants left behind by Hawaii’s plantation era.
Since no biomonitoring data is available prior to the 2023 wildfires, the current study has no way to determine how much was potentially due to the wildfire directly versus ongoing exposures.
According to Maunakea, a John A. Burns School of Medicine professor, many studies on wildfire health effects have focused on the smoke generated by burning vegetation.
But the Lahaina fire — and an increasing number of fires — are wildland-urban interface fires, which burn a combination of homes, vehicles, electronics, treated lumber, plastics, and electrical systems.
Many buildings in Lahaina were built before 1980, and therefore the debris and ash potentially could include lead, asbestos, arsenic and other hazardous materials. Arsenic, used as an herbicide, also may be present in the soil in Hawaii.
Lahaina residents showed relatively elevated concentrations of arsenic and cadmium, while Wailuku and Kahului residents had the highest median concentrations of copper, iron and molybdenum, according to researchers.
Based on breathing test results, Wailuku/Kahului residents had some of the highest abnormal lung-function measures, while Kula generally showed the lowest burden.
“The biggest message is that exposure may not end when the smoke clears,” said Ruben Juarez, MauiWES co-director and health economics professor, in the release. “What we are likely seeing is a complex combination of exposures — some that may have been present for years and others that may have been generated or remobilized by the wildfire. When a disaster burns through a community, it can fundamentally change how contaminants move through the environment. The next scientific challenge is to disentangle those sources and understand which exposures persist, where they come from and what they mean for long-term health.”
The Maui Wildfire Exposure Study has been tracking a cohort of survivors since shortly after the disaster, with plans to continue through 2031 due to an award of nearly $6 million from the National Institutes of Health.

