Man who killed Maui officer to serve life in prison
MAUI POLICE DEPARTMENT
Clembert Alii Kaneholani
MAUI POLICE DEPARTMENT
Maui police officer Suzanne O as she appeared in a MPD recruitment video.
Prosecutors will ask a judge to impose the “maximum sentence allowed by law” when sentencing a Makawao man convicted of shooting and killing Maui Police Department Officer Suzanne O on Aug. 15, 2025.
Clembert Alii Kaneholani, 39, was convicted Thursday after a two-week trial of murder in the first degree, first- degree reckless endangering and five firearm offenses. He will serve life in prison without the possibility of parole for the first-degree murder conviction.
On Monday, a Maui jury returned findings that Kaneholani was subject to extended terms of 10 years in prison on four of the firearm charges and life with the possibility of parole for the fifth.
“The State will be asking the Court to impose the maximum sentence allowed by law, including the imposition of the extended terms, and that the sentence for each count run consecutively,” Maui Prosecuting Attorney Andrew H. Martin told the Honolulu Star-Advertiser in a statement.
At about 8:26 p.m. on Aug. 15, 2025, O and other MPD officers went to the Paia Sugar Mill off Baldwin Avenue after a caller reported that Kaneholani had trespassed onto the property and shot at them.
When the officers arrived, they found Kaneholani, who opened fire with a 9mm pistol, fatally striking the 37-year-old O. Officers returned fire, hitting Kaneholani in the hip. O, a five-year veteran of the department, was shot in the chest and died after efforts to save her were unsuccessful.
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with breaking news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It's FREE!
Kaneholani was charged with first-degree murder, first-degree attempted murder, carrying a firearm in the commission of a separate felony, two counts of carrying a gun as a felon and possession of a prohibited pistol magazine.
Kaneholani was accused of carrying a handgun and beating the mother of his children two days before the fatal shooting of Officer O in Paia.
In a statement on Thursday, acting MPD Chief Wade Maeda said “justice was served for the family, colleagues, and community” of Officer Suzanne O.
“While no amount of time in a prison cell can replace the loss of Officer O or heal the pain her family and loved ones carry every day, today’s sentence ensures this dangerous individual will never again threaten our community,” said Maeda, in a statement. “We are encouraged by today’s decision and the momentum it brings toward passage of the Suzanne O bill in the upcoming Legislative session. The Maui Police Department will forever honor Officer O’s ultimate sacrifice and continue to uphold her legacy.”
O moved to Maui from Oahu after graduating from Farrington High School in 2006.
She played on the Governors’ girls varsity soccer team and was president of Island Harmony, Farrington’s Polynesian and Pacific Islander club.
On Tuesday, the State of Hawaii Organization of Police Officers said that O spent every day serving her community, protecting our neighborhoods, caring for her family and being a “good friend to her fellow officers.” She led by example because she knew young girls looked up to her as a role model, someone they aspired to be like.
“Officer Suzanne O’s SHOPO brothers and sisters, both in the Maui Chapter and statewide, are profoundly grateful to the jury for returning a verdict that makes life without the possibility of parole a reality. Your decision sends a clear message that murder in our community will not be tolerated, and that the murder of a police officer carries the strictest punishments allowed by law.
“We thank the prosecution team for standing up for Suzanne, and we strongly urge them to pursue life without parole during sentencing,” said Kenneth Carroll, SHOPO Maui Chapter chair. “A family never fully recovers when a loved one is murdered. Grief for a child, a parent, a sibling, or a close friend may soften over time, but it never truly goes away. No verdict can ever balance the scales for Suzanne’s life being stolen from us. However, there is a small sense of justice in knowing that for every day Suzanne’s family grieves, her killer will remain locked in a cell, forced to live with himself.”

