• Sunday, October 14, 2018
  • 77°

Top News

Former Honolulu Advertiser publisher Twigg-Smith dies

  • COURTESY TWIGG-SMITH FAMILY

    Thurston Twigg-Smith, a fifth-generation scion of island missionaries, was born in Honolulu on Aug. 17, 1921.

ADVERTISING

Thurston Twigg-Smith, a scion of missionary descendants who led the once-weaker Honolulu Advertiser into Hawaii’s dominant newspaper, died Saturday at the age of 94.

Twigg-Smith served as publisher of the Advertiser from 1961 to 1993 until his Persis Corp. sold the newspaper to the Gannett Corp. But everyone from governors to copy boys referred to him simply as “Twigg,” said former Advertiser Editor Gerry Keir.

Under Twigg-Smith’s control, he and the late Advertiser editor George Chaplin were credited with bringing the newspaper’s parochial and ultraconservative reputation more in line with Hawaii’s multi-cultural readership.

“Before Twigg took over, the paper had been stridently right-wing, anti-statehood, sometimes racist, too close to the haole elite,” Keir said. “Anti-union editorials ran on the front page. The paper once advocated tuition for public high schools to inhibit ‘stuffing book knowledge’ into local kids.”

A key moment for the Advertiser under Twigg-Smith’s leadership came in 1962 when the paper endorsed U.S. Senate candidate Daniel K. Inouye over Republican Ben Dillingham, whose father, Walter, was on The Advertiser’s board of directors at the time.

Walter Dillingham resigned from the board in protest.

In the decades that followed, Twigg-Smith continued to acquire admirers, critics and plenty of contemporary art by local artists — which he proudly displayed throughout The News Building on Kapiolani Boulevard that housed The Advertiser, and later its long-time rival, the Honolulu Star-Bulletin. He also was the key figure in creation of The Contemporary Museum.

Twigg-Smith owned “the world’s most complete and most valuable collection of stamps and postal history of Hawaii,” Chaplin wrote in his book, “Presstime in Paradise: The Life And Times of The Honolulu Advertiser 1856-1995.”

Twigg-Smith’s collection included the “Parisian Murder” stamp — an object that Life magazine once called “The most valuable substance on earth.”

Twigg-Smith — whose grandfather, Lorrin A. Thurston, helped orchestrate the overthrow of the Hawaiian kingdom — also collected plenty of critics when he wrote a 1998 book entitled, “Hawaiian Sovereignty: Do The Facts Matter?”

Barbara Hastings, a former science writer at the Advertiser, edited the book and her firm, Hastings & Pleadwell: A Communication Company, oversaw the book’s production, distribution and promotion.

“At the time he was writing an occasional commentary on the Hawaiian sovereignty issue from the point of view of a missionary descendant and grandson of Lorrin Thurston,” Hastings remembered. “He was troubled by what he saw were negative and distorted things being said of his grandfather. He decided to put his thoughts and research into a book, thinking that even if it didn’t attract attention at the moment, it would become part of the record for future historians and he hoped would bring more balance to the story.

“He was open to discussing his book and the issues with anyone and boldly participated in panels that might have intimidated a lesser man,” Hastings said. “There were a few times that were unpleasant, as I recall, but Twigg always was respectful of others and I never saw him get angry in the discussions. … I believe that Twigg has been a major factor in the business and economic community of Hawaii through the last half of the 20th century; however, I think that his role is discounted by those who did not find his book politically correct.”

Twigg-Smith, a fifth-generation scion of island missionaries, was born in Honolulu on Aug. 17, 1921.

After serving in several campaigns in World War II, Twigg-Smith came back to Honolulu to work for the family business run by his uncle, Lorrin P. Thurston, and served in every department The Advertiser operated, including a stint as the paper’s managing editor.

The Thurstons had owned the Advertiser since 1899 and Twigg-Smith engineered a takeover of company stock in 1961 to oust his uncle — a maneuver that his uncle never forgave him for.

As a businessman, Twigg-Smith was credited with saving the weaker morning daily newspaper by entering into a joint operating agreement with its larger afternoon rival, the Honolulu Star-Bulletin, in 1962.

The Advertiser reportedly had less than a week’s worth of operating cash on hand at the time, but did own The News building that in March 1963 became the headquarters for both competing newsrooms when their operations merged into a third entity, the Hawaii Newspaper Agency.

“The papers combined ad sales, printing and delivery functions while retaining two fiercely competitive newsrooms on opposite sides of the News Building,” Keir said. “That brought money for more reporters, newer presses. The community benefited as rival teams of larger reporting staffs competed to dig out the news.”

Keir called Twigg-Smith “the best kind of family newspaper owner.”

“He left Chaplin and his staff free to cover the news wherever it led,” Keir said. “It surely made for some uncomfortable mornings when Twigg picked up his Advertiser and discovered a friend’s name on the front page.”

The Advertiser crusaded against faulty school fire alarms, uncovered government purchasing scandals, spotlighted racism at the Pacific Club, got inside the secretive Family Court and shamed legislators who absconded with ‘Iolani Palace office furnishings, Keir said.

Advertiser editorials campaigned against high-rises on Diamond Head and for construction of the USS Arizona Memorial, a new concert hall — and a rail transit system that today has yet to become reality.

Former Advertiser Managing Editor Mike Middlesworth called Twigg-Smith “an excellent newspaperman and as fine a person as you can imagine.”

Under Twigg-Smith, the Advertiser lost 9 cents on every newspaper it delivered to the neighbor islands but “he felt it was important for Hawaii to have a statewide newspaper,” Middlesworth said.

The Advertiser backed all-state sports teams, the statewide spelling bee and Twigg-Smith personally participated in around-Oahu relay races and joined legendary Advertiser columnist Bob Krauss in circumnavigating the neighbor islands on foot — adventures that Krauss chronicled in his columns.

“He felt the Advertiser should be a major contributor to the community,” Middlesworth said. “As far as I’m concerned, that’s the thing that people should remember about Twigg: He was really interested in having the newspaper be a major factor of the community.”

In 1988, champagne broke out in the Advertiser newsroom when the morning paper finally surpassed its evening rival, the Star-Bulletin, in circulation.

By 1993, with combined annual profits topping $60 million, Twigg-Smith’s own heirs showed no interest in taking over the family business and Twigg-Smith sold The Advertiser to Gannett.

When Gannett Co. sold the Star-Bulletin to Liberty Newspapers Limited Partnership in 1993 to buy the morning Advertiser, the Star-Bulletin’s daily circulation was about 88,000 and the Advertiser’s was approximately 105,000.

In June 2010, the Advertiser merged with its long-time rival, the Star-Bulletin to become the Honolulu Star-Advertiser.

Although he had sold the longtime family paper years earlier, Twigg-Smith retained an affectionate interest in its fortunes, Keir said.

He told Keir in an email that the Advertiser’s demise as a separate publication was “a terribly bleak occasion,” Keir remembered.

Twigg-Smith is survived by his wife, Sharon Twigg-Smith of Honolulu; daughters, Margaret Fivash of Sequim, Wash.; Evelyn Twigg-Smith of Kamuela; sons, Thurston Twigg-Smith Jr. of Barnard, Vt.; and William Twigg-Smith of Barnard, Vt. and Honolulu; stepsons, Nathan Smith of Honolulu; and Gabriel Smith of San Diego, Calif.; 16 grandchildren and 11 great-grandchildren.

There will be a celebration of life at Thurston Chapel at Punahou School on Aug. 27 at 10 a.m.

22 comments

Leave a Reply

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the TERMS OF SERVICE. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. Because only subscribers are allowed to comment, we have your personal information and are able to contact you. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. To report comments that you believe do not follow our guidelines, email commentfeedback@staradvertiser.com.
    • Twigg was one of the best, ever. His interest in collecting contemporary art was world class, right here at home. Making him one of a kind and a true diamond in the rough. Today’s iteration of the local newspaper, the Star Advertiser reflects the every day excellent he and Chaplin brought to the game. Let’s not forget Chaplin, who came here from I think New Orleans? Also story fails to mention Laila, who played a large role in his collection for a period of time.

      • I did read his book about facts that need to be considered. It was very courageous to print the truth as all the illusion in the sovereignty world is rampant and is strictly enforced.

        • It was my privilege to know Twigg and to meet with him for several lengthy discussions during the past 20 years. About ten years ago he gave me permission to post on my website a pdf copy of his entire 375-page book, “Hawaiian Sovereignty: Do the Facts Matter” thereby generously making it available to everyone free of charge. That was especially important because bookstores controlled by sovereignty activists were refusing to stock the book, such as the bookstore in the Palace barracks, University of Hawaii and community college bookstores, Revolution books, etc. Also some bookstores found it impossible to keep copies available for public browsing because sovereignty activists were scribbling nasty comments in them or ripping out pages or otherwise vandalizing them, which also happened to some copies in the libraries — typical behavior by hooligans who want to censor or destroy anything they disagree with, as has happened in recent years when Muslim extremist groups like Taliban, Al Qaida, and Daesh (Isis) have destroyed ancient Buddha statues, Roman ruins, and medieval Christian libraries. Twigg’s book can be downloaded at
          http://tinyurl.com/6osxwp

        • The news report fails to mention that Twigg’s great-great grandparents were Asa Thurston and Lucy Goodale Thurston, who were in the very first company of Christian missionaries who arrived here in 1820. Some of Twigg’s great-grandchildren are the seventh generation of Caucasians to be born and raised in Hawaii, but whom the ethnic nationalists say are mere “settlers” or “guests” and have no right to be treated as full partners in Hawaii.

  • Well what your grandparents did was wrong and illegal that’s why fate will get to you..but other than that whatevas…reply if u want I could careless. .

    • Remember that the missionaries were invited to Hawaii by Henry Opuakahaia, a Hawaiian whose parents were killed during the civil war of Kamehameha the Great. Was the invitation illegal? Were the diseases that were brought to Hawaii by foreigners illegal? Were the visits by Hawaiian wahine to the anchored foreign ships illegal? Was the fascination by Hawaiians of foreign cultural gadgets illegal? Was the adoption of Christianity by Kaahumanu illegal? There was no illegal takeover of Hawaii: instead there was engulfment of Hawaiian by global trade which was made possible by the Alii’s desire for material wealth, and the human fascination with material goods that eliminate old ways in favor of new trends.

      • all true. And Kam III eagerly sought out advice about a liberal democratic constitution as he felt Hawaiians were capable of democracy. As did the missionaries. Many sovereignty folks do not. They want an authoritarian government with all free speech smashed.

  • The missionaries came “to do good” and ended up “doing extremely well.” Lol. What’s that old adage? Oh yes, the road to hell is paved with “good intentions.” The rest is history. When that history is written by a descendant of one of the prime usurpers of the Hawaiian monarchy, it comes from a white ethnocentric perspective.

Scroll Up