Some North Shore residents question HFD response
A Haleiwa man and his neighbors say city first responders stood back as they shouted out to them during historic flooding, asking for their help as he and his children struggled for their lives against fast-moving waters.
Residents claim that a Honolulu Fire Department truck was posted at the intersection of Haleiwa Beach Road and Waialua Beach Road during the powerful Kona-low storm March 20, and that firefighters allegedly watched but did nothing as Philip Holman held onto his 2-year-old son and 4-year-old daughter as a strong current threatened to carry them away.
Holman recalled holding onto his children for as long as 20 minutes while calling out for help, “and they were kind of just staying there, just kind of staring at us.”
Brook Chandler said he was up to his neck in floodwaters as he and others also called out to the firefighters, begging them to help their neighbors.
“The Fire Department is sitting right there, and we’re like, ‘Turn on your sirens!’ You could hear screams all around, it was like a horror movie,” he said. “There’s people screaming and (a firefighter) just shook his head at me.”
Brian Nolan, who also watched the scene unfold, said that when he called 911, the person at the other end of the line “told me ‘good luck’ as I told them little kids are being swept away.”
Don't miss out on what's happening!
Stay in touch with breaking news, as it happens, conveniently in your email inbox. It's FREE!
“Young children are actively being taken as there were firefighters and police standing right there doing nothing,” he said. “People were struggling to get out of here and they were watching them (and) doing nothing.”
More than a week later, residents along Haleiwa Beach Road are wondering what sorts of policies, gaps in training or lack of equipment might have shaped how firefighters responded that day.
“I kind of understand, like, if they have a policy,” Holman remarked. “But at the end of the day, if people are in need, (expletive) your little policy.”
There have been widespread complaints among North Shore residents who in some cases say they either never saw first responders during the peak crisis period or that they did not come to them at all during the Kona-low episode.
When asked specifically about personnel posted at the intersection in question, an HFD spokesperson said in a statement that “prior to your inquiry, the Honolulu Fire Department was not aware of these more direct allegations regarding emergency response operations in Haleiwa during (the March 20) flooding event.”
“We understand how traumatic and frightening emergencies of this magnitude can be, especially for ohana with kupuna and keiki, and we take community concerns seriously,” the statement said.
Holman, who was born and raised on the North Shore and also has a 10-year-old son, recalled that as the storm rolled in, he tried to stay awake to keep an eye on his leaking roof. He dozed off around 1 a.m. March 20 but woke up not long after that.
“I had a really bad feeling something was really wrong,” he said.
When Holman went out to his porch, he noticed the water in his yard had risen from about 6 inches from when he’d fallen asleep to closer to 5 or 6 feet.
“My wife’s car was floating across the driveway and it smashed into the fencing, and then my boat also followed and smashed into fencing, so it kind of blocked us in so we weren’t able to get anything out,” he said. “From there, like, we’re just scrambling. I got my three kids and my wife and we all kind of single-filed it.”
As his family made their way to the road, “there were two different currents colliding with each other and it’s creating, like, a really crazy rapid right there. And then we were stuck there for awhile.”
After calling out to firefighters to no avail, a friend of Holman’s braved the strong current to help them to safety.
”Thank God he was even there,” Holman said. “I don’t think we could have made it out of that water.”
Holman went back alone to his house to get his two dogs but was only able make it to a neighbor’s house. He ultimately rescued one of his dogs but the other remains missing.
Holman said he is left with many questions about HFD policies, training and resources, but added that after he and his family had gotten themselves to safety, a group of firefighters in a raft did eventually make their way into the flooded neighborhood offering help to several residents, though he said he isn’t sure which fire station they were assigned to or where they came from.
HFD said in its statement that along with all other agencies involved in the Kona-low response on Oahu’s North Shore, it “is currently conducting its own investigations and information collection processes to better understand the circumstances, including on-scene conditions, operational priorities/limitations, and safety considerations that may have influenced response actions during a rapidly evolving, large-scale flooding incident.”
“If appropriate, additional details will be shared once the review process is complete,” the statement said. “Our priority during emergency operations is always the safety and preservation of life, both for the public and responding personnel.”
RELATED
>> Scrutiny over stream maintaintence grows after devastating North Shore flooding
>> Recent storms trigger widespread cancellations, stalling tourism rebound
>> Wahiawa Dam ‘not designed for flood control’
>> Kokua Line: How long will debris mound stay at Oahu park?
>> Column: A wake-up call is of no use if we never heed the alarm

