Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Saturday, November 21, 2026 76° Today's Paper


David Shapiro: A wake-up call is of no use if we never heed the alarm

David Shapiro

Each time Hawaii is smacked by a major storm, we hear cries that it’s a wake-up call to address our aging infrastructure as climate change brings more frequent and severe natural disasters.

Then we hit the snooze button until the next disaster hits and cries of a wake-up call are heard anew.

Will the Kona-low storms that flooded much of the state two weeks in a row — putting lives at risk, causing billions of dollars in damage and overwhelming our infrastructure — finally wake us up?

It’s a daunting challenge, to be sure.

After expending massive energy and revenue to recover from the last disaster, it’s against human nature for lawmakers to want to dive right back in with even more energy and dollars to prepare for future disasters — especially as they struggle to balance tight budgets in a down economy, with federal aid we used to depend on scarce.

But heavier rains will fall and other disasters loom, and there’s a time when threats to life and precious resources are so great that we just can’t afford to snooze anymore.

The decades-long worldwide effort to reduce greenhouse gases and slow climate change has failed.

Hawaii can do its best to reduce our carbon footprint, but it makes minimal difference when industrial powers like the U.S., China and India continue to burn oil and coal with little restraint. If anything, effects of climate change have advanced even faster than expected.

Having failed at prevention, we’re in the mitigation stage — finding ways to harden our shorelines, communities, infrastructure and personal safety to survive the changing climate.

We’ve known this for years, but have barely begun the work, which appears so overwhelming and faces so much contention from conflicting interest groups.

State Transportation Director Ed Sniffen hit the magnitude of the challenge when he noted our roadways and other key infrastructure were designed decades ago to withstand the rare 100-year storm. But what happens when storms previously considered once-in-a-century events occur several times a year?

The solution is more than repairing roadways; it requires costly regional infrastructure reengineering, a tough political sell when there are so many immediate needs and limited funds.

But climate impacts those other concerns — cost of living, public safety, affordable housing and homelessness, quality of life.

Ray Tsuchiyama, a management consultant, notes that the Federal Emergency Management Agency worried in a 2011 report after Hurricane Katrina that it would be overwhelmed by the number and magnitude of disasters and more responsibility would have to shift locally — not only to state and local governments, but individual communities.

Oahu seemed well-suited for such a “whole community” approach with its system of neighborhood boards, but the boards are as likely fighting mitigation efforts out of parochial concerns as planning them.

We can no longer delay a committed effort to identify what can be saved and what ultimately must be abandoned, what it will take to protect what we can, how to pay for it and — most importantly — start the work.

Or we can keep snoozing and fighting and wait to be swamped.

RELATED

>> Scrutiny over stream maintaintence grows after devastating North Shore flooding

>> Recent storms trigger widespread cancellations, stalling tourism rebound

>> Some North Shore residents question HFD response

>> Wahiawa Dam ‘not designed for flood control’

>> Kokua Line: How long will debris mound stay at Oahu park?


Reach David Shapiro at volcanicash@gmail.com.