Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Thursday, May 2, 2024 73° Today's Paper


Ramp up efforts on homelessness

1/1
Swipe or click to see more

DENNIS ODA / DODA@STARADVERTISER.COM

The new numbers on homelessness are less than stellar. Homelessness has risen here — discouraging news, viewed in the national context. Hawaii is one of only 14 states and territories, plus the District of Columbia, thatsaw an increase.

Numbers don’t lie, perhaps, but they do tell an incomplete story.

The new numbers on homelessness are less than stellar. Homelessness has risen here — discouraging news, viewed in the national context. Hawaii is one of only 14 states and territories, plus the District of Columbia, that saw an increase.

But the takeaway should not be that state and county efforts are ineffective and should be abandoned. It’s that they have lagged behind the pace necessary to reduce homelessness in a state where conditions make that challenge so difficult.

A federally mandated “point-in-time” survey released last week draws a mixed conclusion. The bad news: The homeless count has risen by 4 percent, statewide.

The good news is that the rise is down from 9 percent and 10 percent increases charted in the 2014 and 2015 tallies, respectively.

On Oahu, especially, the increase was less than 1 percent, signalling that neighbor island counties need more aggressive campaigns. Gov. David Ige has said he plans to ramp up efforts statewide, which is the correct response.

The point-in-time count, taken each January, put the number at 7,921, making Hawaii’s rate the highest among all 50 states. Even in a state with as mild a climate as ours, life on the streets is harsh, hazardous to health and erosive to well-being overall.

The latest unemployment figures show joblessness at historic low levels, so the problem is underemployment in a state with exorbitant costs. People working at minimum wage can barely afford housing without piggybacking multiple jobs and several wage-earners in a single family.

And when there is disruption in earnings from any of them, the household falls short of what it needs for basics of living.

Substance abuse and mental illness plague many among the homeless. Countering these ills is a complex process, but it’s been aided through the implementation of “housing first” programs. People stand a better chance of addressing their health problems, becoming more self-reliant and remaining housed longer if they are given stable housing to begin with.

Those strategies should continue, with counties and state agencies contributing resources.

One reason why other states have progressed much more quickly toward a solution is Hawaii’s sky-high property costs. Investing in more low-cost residential units for the homeless is a simpler matter in states where land doesn’t cost so much.

And overall, island housing inventory is low, with the laws of supply and demand driving up rents beyond what many low-income people can afford.

It helps when affordable inventory expands at all levels, because added housing frees other units for those further down the income scale. There has been some movement on Oahu, thanks a bit to transit-oriented development opportunities along the rail line.

On Oahu, developers such as Stanford Carr have focused efforts on filling the need for workforce housing, It’s encouraging to see gains made on the neighbor islands as well. A proposed apartment complex in West Maui that, along with a single-family subdivision, will yield 882 homes, about half of them at affordable levels.

Financing these projects is not easy, with myriad federal, state and county hurdles to surmount. Lowering these barriers by improving tax incentives and simplifying review processes for developers could bring more players into the affordability game.

Finally, decisionmakers must remain clear-headed about the challenge they face. Steering more of Hawaii’s homeless back to more secure lives does require intervention — even something that could be described as “tough love.”

Honolulu came under fire last week from the National Law Center on Homelessness &Poverty, which issued a report titled “Housing Not Handcuffs.”

This city was among those identified in the report under the banner “Hall of Shame,” singled out primarily for its “sit-lie” ordinance banning sidewalk encampments. The “sweeps” conducted to clear sidewalks were criticized for their disruption and destruction of personal property.

Officials and crews do need to be scrupulous about warning homeless campers to move and take due care with personal property. But the hard fact is that clusters of tents that are simply allowed to persist on sidewalks grow into disease- and crime-ridden eyesores, as everyone who saw the Kakaako Makai encampment can attest.

That is unfair to the rest of the community, which shouldn’t have to live in its midst. And it does no favors for the homeless, either. Most of them will have better lives if guided to housing, even if it takes a nudge to get them on that path.

8 responses to “Ramp up efforts on homelessness”

  1. Wazdat says:

    WHY ? If these people DO NOT WANT TO GO TO A SHELTER then what are you going to do ? We spend a LOT of money on this problem and it will only get WORSE. Tough love and one way tickets are a start. Help the locals and set up a tent city somewhere for other who like living as a homeless person.

  2. Taimalie12 says:

    Most of the increase are the ones coming from the mainland! Gotta stop! They come here to be bums!

    • Tom938 says:

      Winter’s here… gonna get much worse.

    • Cellodad says:

      Accurate data is difficult to obtain. Possibly the most current information is in the State of Hawaii Homeless Point-in-Time Count January 24, 2016 (http://www.honolulu.gov/rep/site/ohou/Statewide_2016_PIT_Report_-_Final.pdf) This independent summary and analysis points out many of the problems in the data collection and analysis process and warns that there are some questions about the data that need to be addressed.

      There are some generalizations one can make however. For many years people have been repeating the trope that it is all those “mainlanders” flooding to the islands that cause the increase in homelessness; particularly on Oahu. The demographic data do not seem to support that conclusion. A look at the data in the tables below shows that, as of the date the Point In Time survey was compiled, the single largest racial/ethnic groups who are homeless on Oahu are Native Hawaiian and Asian/Pacific Islanders. The second largest group was identified as “Multiple Races.”

      HUD HDX Tables 1 -3
      HI-501 Homeless Populations

      One implication that might be drawn here is that it is our very own people who are not being well served by our society. There is no “silver bullet” solution. The breaking of the cycle will likely only happen through a concerted effort to provide a flexible variety of societal responses through education, rehabilitation, housing (both Utah and Finland have had some success here) and other appropriate measures. A viable solution also requires a population committed to effective change. Both the groups directly affected and society as a whole need to want and be prepared to work for substantive solutions rather than cosmetic measures.

      • Cellodad says:

        (I’m sorry, I didn’t close the “/i” statement, hence all the italics) 🙂

      • Mickels8 says:

        I see new mainland homeless near the capitol and Iolani palace almost every day. I’ve talked to the Downtown River of Life administrator and she said most of homeless they assist are recent mainland transplants. Walk around Waikiki and Kapiolani Park and you will see more mainland homeless transplants than locals.

  3. bombay2101 says:

    “Honolulu came under fire last week from the National Law Center on Homelessness &Poverty, which issued a report titled “Housing Not Handcuffs.”

    This city was among those identified in the report under the banner “Hall of Shame,” singled out primarily for its “sit-lie” ordinance banning sidewalk encampments. The “sweeps” conducted to clear sidewalks were criticized for their disruption and destruction of personal property.”

    My first thought was “Who is the National Law Center, and who cares WHAT they say”?

    Then I realized that if the word gets out that Honolulu is in the “Hall of Shame”….GREAT!!! That may serve as the deterrent for future migration of homeless from the mainland!

    Thank you National Law Center, (still don’t care who you are), for sending a message that our politicians have no courage to send.

  4. saveparadise says:

    Ain’t that America? Little pink houses for you and me baby, unless the politicians go and spend all the money on a train. The good you could have done with $8,000,000,000.00? That amount of money is incomprehensible to most and the waste of it will be perpetual in the upkeep.

Leave a Reply