comscore Cup sailor sues Oracle Racing for legal fees | Honolulu Star-Advertiser
Sports | Top News

Cup sailor sues Oracle Racing for legal fees

Honolulu Star-Advertiser logo
Unlimited access to premium stories for as low as $12.95 /mo.
Get It Now
  • AP
    FILE - In this Tuesday

SAN DIEGO >> Sailor Matt Mitchell is suing two-time defending America’s Cup champion Oracle Team USA for the $68,000 he has spent on legal fees fighting accusations he helped illegally alter a catamaran used in a warmup regatta.

Mitchell filed the suit against Oracle Racing Inc. on Wednesday in San Francisco Superior Court. Oracle Racing Inc. is owned by software billionaire Larry Ellison, who isn’t named in the suit.

Mitchell, a grinder, was barred by an international jury from the first four races of the 2013 America’s Cup match as part of the harshest penalties in regatta history.

The New Zealander is seeking his legal fees, plus interest, and special damages for Oracle Racing’s failure to indemnify under the California Legal Code, according to the suit.

Oracle officials and Mitchell’s attorney didn’t respond to requests for comment Friday.

Mitchell’s lawsuit is the latest development in case that continues to affect former Oracle Team USA sailors some 15 months after the syndicate overcame harsh penalties to stage one of the biggest comebacks in sports. Docked two points in the standings, Oracle won eight straight races to rebound from an 8-1 deficit to retain the oldest trophy in international sports.

Mitchell contends he has "sustained and continues to sustain substantial economic damages."

The harshest penalties were given to Dirk de Ridder, a key crewman who was banned from the America’s Cup by the International Sailing Federation’s international jury and later suspended for five years by ISAF.

ISAF later reduced the suspension to three years. Last week, the Court of Arbitration for Sport, finding fault with both de Ridder and ISAF, reduced the suspension to 18 months, meaning the Dutch sailor will be able to compete in sanctioned events starting March 1. De Ridder has denied involvement.

De Ridder was unable to accept a $500,000 contract to sail in the Volvo Ocean Race, which began in October.

CAS ruled that De Ridder "gave instructions, express or implied," to add weight to a catamaran used in America’s Cup World Series regattas, but decided that a three-year suspension "was disproportionate in light of the circumstances of the case and compared to previous sanctions imposed by the sailing federation in similar matters."

CAS — sport’s highest court — criticized ISAF’s jury and hearing process, saying the jury should not act as both prosecutor and judge.

In April, two New Zealand attorneys and Paul Henderson, a former ISAF president and former International Olympic Committee member, questioned whether Mitchell, de Ridder and other sailors received due process from ISAF.

After reviewing transcripts of the jury hearing from August 2013 — just before the America’s Cup match began — the two New Zealand attorneys criticized the panel in a report in which they said Mitchell and shore crew member Andrew Walker shouldn’t face further discipline by Yachting New Zealand. Walker also was barred from the America’s Cup.

The attorneys wrote that they were "troubled" that the jury didn’t include an allegation of gross misconduct against Oracle’s Simeon Tienpont, who, according to the report, signed an interview record sheet stating that he helped Mitchell modify a 45-foot catamaran that was skippered by British sailing star Ben Ainslie, who was a key member of Oracle’s sailing team.

Tienpont sailed in the America’s Cup.

Comments have been disabled for this story...

Click here to see our full coverage of the coronavirus outbreak. Submit your coronavirus news tip.

Be the first to know
Get web push notifications from Star-Advertiser when the next breaking story happens — it's FREE! You just need a supported web browser.
Subscribe for this feature

Scroll Up