Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Thursday, May 2, 2024 74° Today's Paper


Top News

New images show seaplane that sank in Pearl Harbor attack

1/1
Swipe or click to see more

ASSOCIATED PRESS

This June 12, 2015 photo provided by the University of Hawaii Marine Option program shows the wreck of a seaplane downed during the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. New images of the plane show a coral-encrusted engine and reef fish swimming in and out of a hull.

New images of a large U.S. Navy seaplane that sank in Hawaii waters during the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor show a coral-encrusted engine and reef fish swimming in and out of a hull.

The video and photos are the clearest images taken of the Catalina PBY-5 wreckage to date, said Hans Van Tilburg, a maritime archaeologist with the Office of National Marine Sanctuaries.

The site isn’t publicly accessible, so the images allow scientists to share the wreckage with others. They also help with documenting a historically significant wreck over time.

The seaplane had a wing span of 100 feet, about comparable to a modern-era Boeing 727 commercial jet. It now sits in pieces 30 feet below the surface in Kaneohe Bay next to a Marine Corps base, about 20 miles east of Pearl Harbor on the other side of Oahu.

There were an estimated six of these planes — also called “flying boats” — in the bay at the time of the attack, but Van Tilburg said nobody is sure what happened to the others.

The base, which was then a naval air station, was among several Oahu military installations attacked by Japanese planes on the morning of Dec. 7, 1941.

Van Tilburg said a mooring cable is still attached to the plane, but there are signs someone started the port engine before the plane sank. This indicates a crew may have died while attempting to take off as the aerial assault began.

The Catalina PBY-5 could hold an eight-man crew, and four 500-pound bombs.

Standard practice was to keep someone on the seaplanes at night to make sure the aircraft didn’t drift off. There were aviator casualties in the water, but it’s not known which planes they were on or when they got off, Van Tilburg said.

“That’s one of the mysteries of the story,” he said.

The seaplanes would have been priority targets because they could fly as far as 2,000 miles and would have been able to follow Japanese planes back to their aircraft carriers, Van Tilburg said.

Van Tilburg said the plane is a battlefield casualty, just like better-known counterparts like the USS Arizona and other vessels bombed in Pearl Harbor. Van Tilburg said Friday he imagines commanders rightfully assumed the plane was a total loss and not worth salvaging.

There’s been no “dedicated discussion” to retrieving the plane, which is currently in three large pieces, he said. It would cost a great deal to stabilize it and bring it ashore.

The aluminum and other metals may leech over time, but that fact must be balanced with habitat the plane provides for fish and other marine life, Van Tilburg said. The site has become a living reef, he said.

The wreck helps tell the story of what happened at Kaneohe Bay, where 18 sailors and two civilians were killed. Sixty-nine others at the base were injured.

More than 2,400 sailors, Marines, soldiers and civilians were killed across Oahu in the Japanese attack.

9 responses to “New images show seaplane that sank in Pearl Harbor attack”

  1. HanabataDays says:

    Interesting, especially the issue of planes whose fate is said to be unknown. The installation of three PBY squadrons at Kaneohe had only been completed a couple of months earlier. There were actually dozens of PBYs at Kaneohe that morning (most were on land), and all were destroyed save three that were on dawn patrol.

    Dave Trojan of the Hawaii Aviation Preservation Society wrote this 20-page, lavishly-illustrated PDF:

    http://www.j-aircraft.com/research/David_Trojan/TheyStoodtheWatch.pdf

    He says four were in the bay. Presumably the other three were also sunk/burned/blown up by bombs.

    Here’s a NOAA link to more photos and videos of the newly discovered planes:

    http://sanctuaries.noaa.gov/shipwrecks/pby-5/

    One editing note: The aluminum may “leach”, not “leech”, over time.

  2. mikethenovice says:

    Technology has it now that no one can rest in peace anymore.

  3. mikethenovice says:

    Americans just want to rekindle the past war with Japan right in their face, year after year. Can’t we just bury this, and shake hands going forward?

  4. mikethenovice says:

    Isn’t there is square foot of Earth that mankind hasn’t touched, yet?

  5. mikethenovice says:

    After the research has been done, it will become a money making mecca for the tourist industry to capitalize themselves to the bank.

    • SueH says:

      Did you get the part about the plane being located in an area that is not publicly accessible, so tourists wouldn’t even be able to visit its present location. Also, “There’s been no “dedicated discussion” to retrieving the plane”, so it’s unlikely it will be moved to where it could be viewed. Hardly potential for “a money making mecca for the tourist industry”.

  6. wrightj says:

    What is the red material in the photo?

  7. Snator says:

    “New Images”? I only see one picture here. 🙁

Leave a Reply