comscore Officials say they cannot enforce Hawaii fishing contracts | Honolulu Star-Advertiser
Top News

Officials say they cannot enforce Hawaii fishing contracts

Honolulu Star-Advertiser logo
Unlimited access to premium stories for as low as $12.95 /mo.
Get It Now

    A Federal law enforcement officer talks to foreign fishermen in Hawaii’s commercial fleet during a vessel inspection today, in Honolulu.

Federal officials cannot enforce a contract being proposed by the commercial fishing industry as a solution to concerns about foreign fishing crews in Hawaii, leaving the industry responsible for enforcing its own rules.

Federal and state officials met with vessel owners, captains and representatives from the fleet today at a pier in Honolulu.

The normally private quarterly meeting was opened to media and lawmakers to discuss conditions uncovered in an Associated Press investigation that found some foreign fishermen had been confined to vessels for years.

U.S. Custom and Border Protection “does not review contracts, we just make sure that these fishermen … are employed on the vessel,” said Ferdinand Jose, Custom and Border Protection supervisory officer. “Whatever you negotiate … is between you folks, not us.”

The Hawaii Longline Association, which represents fishing boat owners, created a universal contract that will be required on any boat wanting to sell fish in the state’s seafood auction.

A loophole in federal law allows the foreign men to work, but it exempts them from most basic labor protections. Because the men do not have visas, they have no legal standing to enter the United States and therefore must not leave the secured piers where they are docked. The entire system by which the fishermen are allowed to work on American-owned, American-flagged vessels contradicts other state and federal laws.

The AP investigation discovered some men were living in squalor, forced to use buckets instead of toilets, and suffered running sores from bed bugs. The AP also found that federal officials issued two men from Indonesia who worked in Hawaii waters special visa designations for victims of human trafficking, but officials said Thursday that despite many allegations over the years, they have not found any instances of trafficking in the fleet.

“Certainly, the nature of the fishing industry makes it susceptible to labor trafficking, and that is one of the reasons we have these meetings,” said Joanna Ip, special agent in charge for Homeland Security Investigations in Hawaii. “We have received many allegations that could be construed as human trafficking … but we haven’t come across a case yet.”

Of the 167 fishing vessels in the fleet, 143 of them employ a total of about 620 foreign men. About 20 owners or their representatives showed up for the meeting on Thursday.

The foreign men are allowed to leave their boats if they want to end their contracts, have disputes or need to return to their home countries for emergencies. Federal officials will parole fishermen who need to enter the United States, which allows them to be escorted off the vessels and flown off the islands.

In 2015, there were “663 total paroles for various reasons: medical needs, a need to go to the consulate to renew a passport , or, ultimately, parole for immediate departure,” said Custom and Border Protection’s Brian Humphrey, the director of the San Francisco and Portland, Oregon, field offices, which oversees Hawaii. Of those, 296 paroles were issued for fishermen whose contracts expired and they wanted to return home or for men who wanted to leave early.

“If they want to leave before their contract expires, that’s not our issue to argue. If someone tells us they want to return home, we will make accommodations,” he said.

But vessel owners hold the men’s documents, and getting back home can be expensive. Boat owners on Thursday said they always pay for crews to return if they have to, but the AP investigation showed at least one fisherman from Kiribati had deductions from his pay including $1,300 for airfare, $1,800 to pay for his replacement and $2,100 for breaking a captain’s computer.

Workers are paid a fraction of what other U.S. fishing fleets pay their mostly American crews. Some of Hawaii’s workers make less than $5,000 a year, while experienced American crew members in Alaska can make up to $80,000 a year.

Federal law requires that U.S. citizens make up 75 percent of the crew on most commercial fishing vessels in America. The fleet in Hawaii has an exemption carved out years ago, largely by lawmakers no longer in office.

To many of the workers, the meager pay is good compared with what they would make in their home countries, and many fishermen return to the fleet year after year to work and provide for their families.

On Wednesday, Hawaii state Rep. Kaniela Ing held a public meeting at the state Capitol on the issue. Ing and other lawmakers pressed representatives from the fishing industry and government agencies about what can be done to increase oversight and improve conditions in the industry.


Associated Press writer Cathy Bussewitz contributed to this report from Honolulu.

Comments (5)

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Terms of Service. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. Report comments if you believe they do not follow our guidelines.

Having trouble with comments? Learn more here.

Leave a Reply

  • If there is no oversight by government, there will be abuses. If the boats dock at US ports, if the fish is sold in the US, if US companies make money off of these workers, then the workers are due US pay. Forget that old saw that what they earn is really great compared to what they would be paid at home. We are Americans, we do not profit off the backs of the poor, the underprivileged, and the underpaid. The AP story provided some substantial evidence of abuses. The fish auction, the wholesalers, and the fish buyers can clean up this situation forthwith by requiring every boat owner and captain to sign this contract and to provide a printed statement of pay and benefits tacked on to the wall of the vessel which is visible to all. This is like the same notices we have in the US as to minimum wage and workers rights. These workers are in the US, but are in a limbo status and that is not acceptable. If you are in the fish business and you do not want these workers to be fairly paid, then you are buying slave-fish. We are in an international economy now, not a colonial economy.

    • Kukuinunu: Your opening statement is SO TRUE! Mahalo for sharing your thoughts. Since the CBP is unable to enforce a contract and some of the state legislators are attempting to help these men. It’s TIME for Hawaii’s congressional delegation to step-in and repeal or modify the exemption. Honestly, the AP investigative reporting was an eye-opener. What’s it going to take? A boycott? Please, Hawaii Longline Association STOP the abuse, already! Auwe!

    • Most of what you say is good but some is not reality – You say “We are Americans, we do not profit off the backs of the poor, the underprivileged, and the underpaid.” – really? Why do you think that most Anmerican companies have manufacturing plants in developing countries (today it is China, India, Vietnam, Philippines, Cambodia, Bangladesh, etc.). There are reports all the time about abusive practices in these American owned and operated plants. In the past, we even had sweat shops in the U.S. with illegals doing the work at meager pay and working conditions.

      Americans are no different from other nationalities insofar as taking advantage of situations to make a buck.

  • So legally these foreign fishermen are in no man’s land, not under the jurisdiction of the U.S. and Hawaii governments, and not technically domiciled and working in the U.S., including Hawaii. Hence, their working and living conditions are not our problem, and should remain invisible. Problem solved.

Click here to see our full coverage of the coronavirus outbreak. Submit your coronavirus news tip.

Be the first to know
Get web push notifications from Star-Advertiser when the next breaking story happens — it's FREE! You just need a supported web browser.
Subscribe for this feature

Scroll Up