Tourists from China sue Utah over deadly tour bus crash that killed 4, injured dozens
SPENSER HEAPS/THE DESERET NEWS VIA AP / 2019
The remains of a bus that crashed while carrying Chinese-speaking tourists lie along State Route 12 near Bryce Canyon National Park in Utah. The families of Chinese tourists killed or injured in the 2019 tour bus crash say the state’s design and maintenance failed to keep the remote highway safe. More than a dozen people were thrown from the bus when the driver drifted off the road and overcorrected when he steered back, sending the bus into a rollover. A lawsuit alleges the state failed to post warning signs, had a road design that left little room for error and included no rumble strip to warn drivers. The Utah Department of Transportation declined to comment. U.S. regulators have previously ruled out highway design, signage and other characteristics as factors.
SPENSER HEAPS/THE DESERET NEWS VIA AP / 2019
Authorities work the scene of a tour bus crash near Bryce Canyon National Park in Utah. The families of Chinese tourists killed or injured in the crash say the state’s design and maintenance failed to keep the remote highway safe.
SALT LAKE CITY >> The state of Utah didn’t do enough to make sure a remote highway was safe before a tour bus crashed, killing four people from China and injuring two dozen more in 2019, family and survivors said in a lawsuit filed Tuesday.
The lawsuit alleges state transportation officials failed to post warning signs, had a road design that left little room for error and included no rumble strip to warn drivers they were getting close to the edge.
More than a dozen people were thrown from the bus after the driver drifted off the road and overcorrected when he steered back, sending the bus into a rollover. All 30 people on board were hurt.
The lawsuit said the unpaved shoulder was too deep and soft, requiring the driver to steer harder to get back onto the road after passing through a too-narrow buffer zone. It had been repaved the day before, creating a dangerous contrast with the rough shoulder, the lawsuit said.
The Utah Department of Transportation declined to comment on the case filed against it and several contractors, citing its policy on pending litigation. The National Transportation Safety Board previously found highway design, signage and other characteristics were not factors in the crash.
Four people in their 60s died in the crash and several more suffered serious injuries. The group of older adults from China was on a seven-day tour operated by America Shengjia Inc., a tour bus company based in Ontario, California. The tour started in Los Angeles and was set to end in Salt Lake City.
The company is facing at least four lawsuits in federal court in California brought by surviving passengers and family members of those killed, alleging wrongful death, negligence and infliction of emotional distress.
The Utah lawsuit seeks unspecified damages to make up for lost wages, medical bills and emotional suffering. It was first reported by KUTV in Salt Lake City.
The bus crashed a few miles from Bryce Canyon National Park, which is known for its intricately shaped red-rock spires called hoodoos.
The NTSB investigation found a lack of safety standards for bus roofs and windows contributed to the death and injury toll. Its final report, released in June, also cited inconsistent seat belt use and recommended a lane-departure warning system for commercial buses.
The report ruled out driver problems like intoxication or speeding. An earlier report had found the bus had problems starting earlier in the day, but further examination found no mechanical issues or other malfunctions, it said.
The driver had told investigators the road felt “slippery,” and it was newly paved at the time, but tests showed normal friction, the report found.
