Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Saturday, July 13, 2024 84° Today's Paper

Five-0 Redux

Herlinger reveals Toothpick’s secrets

<em>Toothpick (Karl Herlinger) creating mayhem in the season two finale. (Courtesy CBS)</em>
Toothpick (Karl Herlinger) creating mayhem in the season two finale. (Courtesy CBS)

I never thought that the person who would give me the most information about season three of “Hawaii Five-0” would be one of the bad guys. I begged my sources for some intel to find out more information about the new season. The only source who came through for me was the actor who portrays Toothpick/Devon Akina — Hawaii’s own, Karl Herlinger.

Herlinger was kind enough to answer my questions, and while he didn’t give up a lot about the first episode of the new season, “Lā o nā mākuahine,” he did say, “good thing there are commercials, or you wouldn’t be able to breathe. At all.”

We are less than one week away from the season three premiere of “Hawaii Five-0” and I know that the tension that comes from four months of watching repeat after repeat and from the stress of not knowing is beginning to manifest itself in some strange occurrences.

I know everyone is wondering what will happen in the opening episode. We’ve gotten a little information about Christine Lahti joining the cast as Doris McGarrett, the conflict that this creates because of the long awaited McGarrett family reunion, and the double threat as the team hunts down Wo Fat and Delano.

We know that someone dies. But not who — Malia or Kono? We can only guess what the implications of the evil Delano and his minion Toothpick inflicted in “Ua Hala” will be for the Five-0 team.

<em> "Hawaii actor Karl Herlinger channeling his Toothpick persona." (Courtesy Photo) </em>
Hawaii actor Karl Herlinger channeling his Toothpick persona. (Courtesy photo)

You may remember Herlinger from Mike Gordon’s interview before “Toothpick” debuted in “Ua Hala” back in May, as well as my mention of his mayhem making in my open letter to the ‘Five-0’ villains after the end of season two. And you may remember him trying to woo the fans over to the dark side when he attended a July Fan Tweetup thrown in his honor.

Not only is Herlinger an awesome baddie, but he also is a seasoned stage and film actor, as well as an accomplished ventriloquist. His film, “Show Me,” a ventriloquism psychological thriller, which he wrote and stars in, showed in June at the Hollywood Fringe Festival. He became enthralled with performing and ventriloquism when he was a kid, after watching Freddie Morris’s show at Orson’s in Kailua with his puppet “Moku Kahana.”

He most recently filmed an episode of “Dexter,” and he has played a variety of roles on “Lie to Me,” “CSI: Crime Scene Investigation,” “FlashForward,” “Monk,” and “Without A Trace” among others. He has extensive stage experience in New York and leads in many short films, one of which, “Short on Time,” was nominated for an Emmy. He’s come a long way from playing an extra in season twelve of the classic “Hawaii Five-O” when he was a child.

<em> "Karl Herlinger puts up a fight with 'Five-0' fan Monimoob." (Star-Advertiser file) </em>
Karl Herlinger puts up a fight with 'Five-0' fan Monimoob. (Star-Advertiser File)

Herlinger said he likes playing the baddie; he said it seems like he has been getting more characters on “the badass side,” which he said, “is very flattering.” He said he is “just trying to play a real person — tweaking the character so that they seem more human. As an actor you want to play the opposite — you want to find something positive about the character if he is supposed to be bad — with Toothpick the ‘good’ about him seems to have been his focus on his oral hygiene.”

He did tell me that he “loves Toothpick. I love that there’s not much said about him.” He said it allowed him to have “tons of freedom with creating his backstory. It was a lot of fun to dissect the script and look at everything that is said about Toothpick, everything he says, and everything he does. He’s a pro. He’s done it all before. I feel like this isn’t the first time Toothpick and Delano have worked together.”

It seemed to Herlinger that “the way Peter (Lenkov, Executive Producer of “Hawaii Five-0”) wrote the script, there was history there. Unspoken. But history.”

<em> "Actors Karl Herlinger and Taylor Wily." (Star-Advertiser file) </em>
Karl Herlinger and Taylor Wily. (Star-Advertiser File)

I have to agree with him, that Herlinger’s created backstory with Delano and Toothpick being “old pals” seem to work a lot better than the original answer to my question about his preparation for Toothpick, when he said, “Toothpick is baritone. He sings in a barbershop quartet. He likes puppies and mojitos. He’s a synchronized swimming enthusiast, and makes a mean tomatillo sauce.” Yes, unspoken history works way better on screen, Karl.

<em> "Karl Herlinger (center) with the author (left) and Monimoob (right) at Taylor Wily's WrapUm Party." (Courtesy Photo) </em>
Karl Herlinger with the author, left, and Monimoob at Taylor Wily's WrapUm Party." (Courtesy photo)

When I asked him about working on “Hawaii Five-0” he said it “was a dream to do. It felt like a homecoming of sorts.” He was happy to be able to “do what I left Hawaii to study and train for, and then to be able to come home to do it with a very seasoned cast and crew,” which made it even more special. He said it kind of elevated his time on the show “to a different level of awesome.” He said the entire production took “great care of him,” and he had an amazing experience.

“I don’t think there was a single person on that set that I didn’t want to hang out with after shooting was over,” he said. “These are all people you want to chill with.”

He said about series star Alex O’Loughlin, “he’s a fantastic person.  He is very warm, personable, and tells a great joke. While he is clearly one of the biggest draws of the show for the fans, he remains open and humble. He’s no diva. He’s funny, welcoming, and smart.” Herlinger did add with his trademark Toothpick smirk, “it makes sense that nobody likes him or wants to have anything to do with him.”

You’re a funny guy, Karl.

Herlinger is a clever wit, and a great talent, and after two seasons of Hawaii actors putting in good performances in relatively small parts, I’m glad one got a shot at a role that was a bit more significant. And definitely memorable. Fans and regular viewers alike won’t forget Toothpick. And I’m glad that someone who has as much experience as Herlinger was able to come home to Hawaii and take on “Five-0.” For the first time, I’m hoping the bad guy doesn’t get killed off in the end. But I’m not going to hold my breath.

Redux Side Note:

This week’s “Hawaii Five-0” was the repeat of the season two ender “Ua Hala,” when Herlinger first showed Toothpick off to the world. You can follow Herlinger on Twitter and like his Facebook page, for his short film “Show Me,” or bookmark his website.

Sept. 24 is the season three television premiere, “Lā o nā mākuahine,” or “Mother’s Day,” when all of our questions will be answered. We hope.

If you are in Hawaii on Sunday, Sept. 23, be sure to come down to Waikiki Beach for the “Season 3 World-Premiere at Sunset on the Beach” at 7:00 p.m. I would come down early to get parking and to find a seat in the sand. You can follow along at www.honolulupulse.com.
Wendie Burbridge is a published author, playwright and teacher who lives and works in Honolulu. Reach her via Facebook and follow her on Twitter.

16 responses to “Herlinger reveals Toothpick’s secrets”

  1. Bri says:

    Fantastic Wendie! Karl has been fun to follow on twitter and i love the new insight you’ve given all of us 🙂 Two things, first,very cool to see that “Toothpick” actually has a real character name and second you called him a “minion” teehee. Can’t wait to hear your opinion about the season premiere next week 🙂 Oh and good luck on the red carpet on Sunday *huggles*

  2. Diane says:

    He does play a great bad guy. It would be interesting to see some back ground on his character. Thanks for the interview. Counting the hours at this point for Monday. Have fun at SOTB 3.

    • Wendie Joy says:

      Thanks Diane- this was my SOTB 3 teaser- it was a treat to have a chance to write something a little different before the season premiere. And Karl was a great subject to cover. Thanks for reading and supporting the Redux:) Aloha, Wendie

  3. Dina says:

    Karl seems like such a down to earth guy- which shows his level of excellence when he plays the bad guy! Great piece Wendy thanks to you and Karl

  4. Mrs. Little says:

    Following karl’s Tweets has been a riot! He has really taken his roll on H50 and run with it. i love all the “Toothpick” and “mayhem” tweets he has been teasing us with this summer. I hope they don’t knock this bad guy off so he can come back for more mayhem!

    • Wendie Joy says:

      He’s a great mayhem maker! It’s been really special for us to tweet with him- it’s nice that he let us get a glimpse into his life and character. Thanks for commenting and for the support, Mrs. Little:) Aloha, Wendie

  5. Terry says:

    As much as I hate “Toothpick,” I love Karl! He’s smart, witty, talented, and a great family guy. I’m so glad he chose to chose to engage Hawaii Five-0 fans on twitter. Thanks for even more insight into this “bad guy” who really isn’t.

    • Wendie Joy says:

      So true Terry- he really is a great guy- Karl, I mean:) Toothpick is just spooky. But Karl is super funny and it’s been a treat to meet him and to write about him. Thanks for your comment and support! Aloha, Wendie

  6. Suzie says:

    Awesome article Wendie, if I didn’t already love Karl this would totally make me & I don’t want them to kill off Toothpick either so much potential for him to be recurring thorn in Five-0’s side like WoFat & who doesn’t want to see Toothpick in his down time synchronize swimming lol. 😉

  7. Go says:

    I would love for his character to come back on H50.

  8. Anonymous says:

    Great post and info on Mr Toothpick. Cannot wait for your report and pictures from the Party on the Beach. Not to mention the start of season 3. Thanks for the summer break time, and now the serious stuff starts.

Leave a Reply