Honolulu Star-Advertiser

Saturday, December 14, 2024 78° Today's Paper


Top News

Rep. Mark Takai wants to stop China from participating in wargames

COURTESY DEPT. OF DEFENSE

Defense Secretary Ash Carter greeted U.S. Rep. Mark Takai at a hearing before the House Armed Services Committee in Washington, D.C., March 22, to testify on the Defense Department’s proposed fiscal year 2017 budget.

U.S. Rep. Mark Takai wants to bar China from participating in this summer’s Rim of the Pacific wargames, saying at a House Armed Services Committee meeting today that China’s behavior in the South China Sea is “the polar opposite of U.S. objectives in the region.”

Takai, a Hawaii Democrat, told Defense Secretary Ash Carter and Gen. Joseph Dunford, chairman of the joint chiefs of staff, that he would follow through with an amendment to the National Defense Authorization Act prohibiting China’s participation if the Pentagon does not revoke the rising Asia power’s RIMPAC invite.

Takai questioned whether China is preparing to conduct land reclamation at Scarborough Shoal, 120 miles from Subic Bay in the Philippines — a step that would greatly increase tensions in the already contested South China Sea.

“Congressman, we’re concerned about that prospect,” Carter said, adding that China is “self-isolating” itself in the region.

“My question then is, why then should we reward China with their aggressive behavior by including them in an event meant for allies and partners?” Takai said of RIMPAC.

Carter told Takai earlier that “we’re constantly evaluating our relationship with China and China’s behavior — including in the South China Sea, where I emphasize, we have very serious concerns about their aggressive militarization.”

China has an invitation to participate in RIMPAC this summer off Hawaii, “and we will continue to review that,” Carter said.

“But you might say, what’s the logic for having them there in the first place?” Carter added. “Our strategy in the Asia-Pacific is not to exclude anyone, but to keep the security architecture going there in which everyone participates.”

The United States is not excluding China from that security architecture “in which America plays the pivotal role — and we intend to keep playing that pivotal role,” Carter said.

However, the United States disinvited Thailand from RIMPAC two years ago following a coup in that country.

The Navy’s 3rd Fleet in San Diego, the planners for RIMPAC, said recently that all 21 foreign nations that participated with the United States in RIMPAC 2014 have been formally invited to return this year to the exercise, which is held every other year.

Carter and Dunford testified today on the fiscal 2017 National Defense Authorization budget request.

News agency Reuters reported that the U.S. military has observed Chinese activity around Scarborough Shoal in the Spratly archipelago west of Subic Bay in the Philippines.

Adm. Harry B. Harris Jr., head of U.S. Pacific Command headquartered at Camp Smith on Oahu, last month accused China of trying to create hegemony in East Asia and destabilization of the South China Sea — where reefs and islands are claimed by multiple countries — with China’s deployment of missile systems to the Paracel Islands and construction of three 10,000-foot runways in the Spratlys.

China has been rapidly building up reefs and islands with land reclamation efforts to support more infrastructure.

China, Vietnam, Malaysia, Taiwan, Brunei and the Philippines have competing claims in the South China Sea. The United States worries China will restrict commercial and military passage in international waters.

“Our policy is that no one ought to be militarizing these features,” Carter said today.

Takai noted that if China builds a runway on Scarborough Shoal, Harris, the Pacific Command commander, has assessed that Beijing would have total access across the South China Sea.

Carter said such a step would prompt an even stronger U.S. military response.

“It’s the kind of behavior that we will react to in our own military posture and deployments, and all regional partners will react to, so it will be self-defeating and self-isolating for China,” Carter said. “So I hope they don’t do that. But we’re prepared for that eventuality should it occur.”

11 responses to “Rep. Mark Takai wants to stop China from participating in wargames”

  1. den says:

    include China for now and study their defense triggers and
    log their ships foot prints by subs then kick them out.

  2. yobo says:

    Good call by Takai. China has been building the spratly island next to the Phillipines.

    It’s a lot better than asking the Speaker of the House Paul Ryan to allow Aloha wear to be worn on the floor.

  3. Dawg says:

    Hahahahhahahahha…first aloha shorts on the house floor…next make Dec 7th a MORE special day…and now exempt China when we can get a closer look. Dude

  4. Dawg says:

    Hahahahhahahahha…first aloha shorts on the house floor…next make Dec 7th a MORE special day…and now exempt China when we can get a closer look. Dude get rid of your Chief of Staff and his Flunky Deputy Dud!

  5. rytsuru says:

    The problem is we aren’t getting a closer look at the Chinese navy. The Chinese on the other hand are getting a front row seat to observe the US and allies. Gathering sonar footprints of vessels? How do we know they aren’t doing that? We wouldn’t even know if one of their nuclear or conventional submarines was lurking around out there. There aren’t many points to agree with in regards to our representatives in DC, but this is something we should support our congressman on.

  6. HawaiiMongoose says:

    Don Corleone said it best: Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer. Anyone who thinks the U.S. Navy isn’t taking advantage of RIMPAC to learn all they can about their Chinese counterparts is naive. No doubt the Chinese are also studying our navy, but U.S. intelligence-gathering technology is probably superior, so the mutual exposure likely works in our favor.

  7. Maipono says:

    China has a lot more to gain politically and technologically by participating in RIMPAC. I like sending them a message that they need to behave to be a part of the rest of the world. Takai is right on this one and I agree entirely.

  8. saywhatyouthink says:

    Takai is grandstanding for the media and folks back home, almost time to run for re-election again.

    • koolau says:

      If this is Takai’s strategy, all he’s demonstrating is how naïve he is about the real world. Notice how his colleagues danced around his suggestions as to not humiliate another of his elementary suggestions. It was no doubt a polite way of saying “no”. HawaiiMongoose’s comment above says more than what Takai doesn’t know. Where are you Ms. Hanabusa?

Leave a Reply