comscore Police: Uncle IDs kids killed in Puna, allegedly by dad | Honolulu Star-Advertiser
Top News

Police: Uncle IDs kids killed in Puna, allegedly by dad

  • COURTESY HAWAII COUNTY POLICE John Ali Hoffman
  • DARYL LEE / SPECIAL TO THE STAR-ADVERTISER

    John Ali Hoffman appeared in District Court in Hilo Monday for an initial appearance after he was charged Friday with murder in the deaths of his wife and two children.

An uncle of two Hawaii children police say were shot to death by their father was given the grim task of identifying their bodies, police said today.

“We were trying to avoid that,” Hawaii Police Capt. Robert Wagner said. “It’s a lasting impression.”

But with limited dental records available — none for the younger child — police asked their mother’s brother for help even though it would be traumatic for him, Wagner said.

Police said they were 7-year-old Clara Hoffman and 5-year-old John Hoffman.

Their father, John Ali Hoffman, remained held on $2.75 million bail and is also charged with murder in the death of his wife. Earlier, police used fingerprints to identify her as Aracely Hoffman, whose name before marriage was Aracely del Carmen Monroy Urruela. Documents found in their home show they were married in 2008, police said.

John Hoffman called police early Friday saying three to four intruders entered the house and shot his wife, according to court documents. Officers who arrived about 1:30 a.m. saw Hoffman driving away in a car with headlights off. They pulled him over, saw a handgun in the front passenger seat and blood dripping from the trunk, police said.

Inside the trunk, police said they found Aracely Hoffman dead with a gunshot wound to her head. The children were dead inside the house, also shot in their heads, police said.

A hearing is scheduled for June 14 to discuss findings of a panel of doctors ordered to evaluate Hoffman’s mental health, said his court-appointed defense attorney Brian De Lima.

Aracely Hoffman immigrated to Hawaii’s Big Island from El Salvador with her brother in search of a better life, said Rose Bautista, an attorney on the island who helped her with immigration issues and went to Mass with her at Malia Puka O Kalani Catholic Church.

“She came however often as she could come,” Bautista said, noting that the Hilo church is about 25 miles away from the rural Puna neighborhood where the Hoffmans lived. She appreciated fellow Spanish-speaking parishioners on an island with only a small Salvadoran community, Bautista said.

Her husband wouldn’t allow the children to be baptized in the Catholic church, Bautista recalled.

“I know there were some language difficulties,” Bautista said. “That’s why she sought comfort in coming to a church … where she could speak the language.”

A bigger source of stress for the couple was her immigration problem, Bautista said.

Married to a U.S. citizen, Aracely Hoffman would have been eligible for permanent resident status, commonly known as a green card. But there were some challenges to obtaining that status, which Bautista declined to discuss.

Bautista met John Hoffman when the couple first began dating and the couple went to her office after they got married.

“He was always angry at the world,” Bautista said. “Angry at the system.”

He didn’t seem to direct that anger at his wife, Bautista said, and she never discussed problems in the marriage.

She kept a lot of things to herself, Bautista said.

“The thing with her, no matter what her situation was at home— which you knew wasn’t the happiest— she always smiled,” Bautista said. “She was always smiling . but you could see it was a painful smile.”

Comments (8)

By participating in online discussions you acknowledge that you have agreed to the Terms of Service. An insightful discussion of ideas and viewpoints is encouraged, but comments must be civil and in good taste, with no personal attacks. If your comments are inappropriate, you may be banned from posting. Report comments if you believe they do not follow our guidelines.

Having trouble with comments? Learn more here.

Leave a Reply

  • I’m jaded, but whenever I hear about people who relocate to a very rural/secluded area without any real job options or expectations, ostensibly “in search of a better life,” I get suspicious. They don’t give the background of the low-life murderer, but I suspect he also moved here for shady reasons.

  • He’s going to claim mental illness and cost taxpayers untold sums of money while keeping himself out of prison. Just what we need, another mass murderer living on the public dime for the rest of his miserable life.
    People who murder innocent children don’t deserve to live no matter what the circumstances were, it’s simply not a defensible crime under any conditions, even mental illness.

    • I agree. People say prison is NOT about “punishment” but rather it’s to keep the public safe. If that’s true, then why shouldn’t we imprison a mentally ill person who kills children? We’re not doing it to punish, but to keep everyone else safe. The counter-argument is that he could be locked up in a mental institution instead, but I don’t agree — those are required to only use the MINIMUM security necessary, and that’s a fine line (too much security, and the hospital gets sued). Also, as soon as the mentally ill person can show they are taking meds, they have to be released (even if it means they will stop taking meds the very next day after release). We need to change our laws.

  • I wonder why he did it? He mentioned something about conspiracy. I’d like to know more about this conspiracy. Regardless, he shouldn’t have done what he did. #Kaaihue4Mayor

Click here to see our full coverage of the coronavirus outbreak. Submit your coronavirus news tip.

Be the first to know
Get web push notifications from Star-Advertiser when the next breaking story happens — it's FREE! You just need a supported web browser.
Subscribe for this feature

Scroll Up